MONUMENT TO CULTURE: Architect Rafael Vinoly's design for the Tampa Museum of Art. Credit: Tampa Museum of Art

MONUMENT TO CULTURE: Architect Rafael Vinoly’s design for the Tampa Museum of Art. Credit: Tampa Museum of Art

Dick Greco had all the fun of planning a grand new cultural arts district for downtown Tampa. Now, like it or not, the next mayor will inherit the actual work and expense of making it a reality.Any large outlay of public resources is bound to generate controversy, and this project is no exception. Even the arts community disagrees about whether a new cultural arts district is the best use of the city’s money. The division was conspicuous in two very different candidate forums hosted by arts groups.

The first took place on the night of the Gasparilla Parade at Covivant, an appropriately scruffy urban art gallery in Seminole Heights. That’s the neighborhood where many local artists and bohemian entrepreneurs ended up after being priced out of Ybor City. The evening, which drew well over 100 people, was actually more of a fundraiser and showcase for District 2 City Council candidate Kelly Benjamin, but mayoral candidates were invited too. Only Frank Sanchez and Don Ardell showed up.

Benjamin set the tone early by declaring his opposition to the cultural arts district, which he characterized as part of a “stale economic package.” He reminded those in attendance that “Ybor City was the cultural arts district.”

He said the city failed to sustain the cultural arts district it had and helped to destroy it. “You make a community by nurturing it,” he said, “not by creating it.” And certainly, he added, not by catering only to the elite, upscale segment of the population with $180,000 condos like those proposed for the cultural arts district.

Sanchez acknowledged the city’s failures in Ybor, saying it should have been given a chance to grow organically and that he hoped to find a way to bring artists and small business back. That brought audible groans from the artists. “Artists and businesses are not going back to Ybor,” said Angelica Diaz, owner of Viva La Frida Cafe y Galeria. She and her restaurant were forced out of Ybor City to make way for Centro Ybor, and she spent years jumping through city hoops to open her new cafe on Florida Avenue in Seminole Heights. “It’s too expensive. Why doesn’t the city support us where we are now?”

Ardell’s answer was to start a mayor’s council on the arts; apparently he’s unaware that there is an arts council that once was a city agency until the excessive spending of another mayor forced his successor to unload it onto the county.

Sanchez pledged to tie city dollars for the Tampa Museum of Art and Tampa Bay Performing Arts Center to their support of local artists.

In a final moment of passion that drew hoots and hollers in addition to applause, Sanchez added, “I will spend as much time in galleries and theaters as some of our other officials spend at Bucs games.” At which point Ardell leapt to his feet and boasted he had never been to a Bucs game.

The other arts forum, sponsored by the Business Committee for the Arts and held at Tampa Theatre, was considerably more sedate, although twice as many people and all of the viable mayoral candidates attended. This was the cultural establishment crowd, with administrators from the Museum of Science and Industry, USF College of Visual and Performing Arts, Contemporary Art Museum, The Florida Orchestra, Henry B. Plant Museum and the Arts Council, among others. Lots and lots of reporters were there too, partly due to the fact that Tampa Tribune Executive Editor and Senior Vice President Gil Thelen was moderating.

The first two questions came from the Business Committee for the Arts and were posed by the moderator. First, he asked candidates whether they would dedicate their administration to completing the cultural arts district and how. Frank Sanchez, Pam Iorio and Charlie Miranda pledged their support of the project, and even Bob Buckhorn expressed lukewarm support with several caveats. Don Ardell dissented, saying some people feel that downtown gets too much attention. Neil Cosentino, in the first of his many non sequiturs of the evening, said he would junk the project and make Franklin Street Mall into an atrium instead.

Sanchez never mentioned his earlier pledge to tie city dollars to support for local artists, though he did say he thought the district would benefit all artists, even those who aren’t downtown.

The second question asked what incentives the candidates would provide to bring artists to downtown and Channelside. It was probably intended as an effort to include local artists in the largesse, but it felt more like a bone tossed carelessly in their direction, with little thought to what they want and with an unsavory implication that artists are props to be moved to wherever they’re needed.

Most of the candidates gave vague answers, saying it isn’t government’s role to subsidize artists, but rather to facilitate the process with tax credits and infrastructure. Iorio fantasized about affordable apartments at the north end of downtown with bookstores, cafes and music stores, but gave no specifics on how she might make that happen. Cosentino continued to puzzle the audience by saying that we don’t need a new art museum because it’s only 30 years old and we have the Kress building.

The rift between local artists and the arts establishment isn’t new, and it isn’t going away any time soon. With limited dollars and seemingly unlimited needs, there will always be competition for resources.To a city constantly trying to appear sophisticated, there’s something seductive about the proposed cultural arts district with its art museum designed by a famous architect, new history center and lavish condos for privileged urban hipsters.

It’s a worthy goal. A vivacious downtown cultural district can improve the overall cultural climate of the area by providing more opportunities to see quality work, supplying more resources to scholars, bringing in art that challenges and inspires local artists and generally creating excitement about cultural events.

But such a district can’t take the place of local artists who bring creativity, vigor and a unique sense of place to a city.

The next mayor needs to find ways to cultivate local artists where they live and work in addition to building pricey monuments to culture.

Contact Susan Edwards at susan.edwards@weeklyplanet.com or 813-248-8888 ext. 122.