Although it’s rated an entirely unproblematic PG and there’s nary a trace of naked skin to be found anywhere within, Together is a thoroughly sensual film in at least one respect. It’s the sort of movie that you feel with your whole body as much as you understand it with your brain.
The organ that’s actually most apt to appreciate Together is the heart, or at least that logic-defying part of the brain that thinks of itself as the heart. That’s because, on its most basic level, Together is a simple, emotion-drenched melodrama, most of it revolving around the love between a gifted young boy and his bumbling but well-meaning father.
The man responsible for Together is the acclaimed Chinese director Chen Kaige, who seems to feel the need to periodically indulge himself in these on-screen father-son lovefests. It’s almost certainly the filmmaker’s public way of expiating lingering guilt for his past treatment of his own father, whom Chen denounced back when the director-to-be was an overzealous teen revolutionary in China during the Cultural Revolution. He’s been atoning ever since, overtly replaying his sins in movies like Farewell, My Concubine, and now, in somewhat less direct fashion, in Together.
The reasons behind the strains in the parent-child relationship are just a touch ambiguous in Chen’s new film, but we feel them nonetheless, much in the same way that one senses whether a piece of music is working or not.
The film is chock full of elemental imagery beginning with the repeated shots of water, which is everywhere in the canal-laced provincial village where 13-year-old Xiaochun (Tang Yun) and his father, Cheng (Liu Peiqi) live. The camera introduces us to Xiaochun as he’s gazing out at a watery horizon, then follows him as he dashes along the canal to a room where a woman’s giving birth, then on to the celebration hall where a noisy crowd stuffs their faces and awaits the new baby. All this in the movie’s first few minutes.
Xiaochun is a child prodigy. He’s a violinist of extraordinary talent who’s constantly being asked to play something to transform or heighten the emotional states of the movie’s various characters.
Xiaochun’s a painfully shy and sensitive kid, but he’s clearly also savvy, much more so than his almost comically naive father. “At least you understand how life works,” says Debao, although it’s unclear if he’s referring to the boy’s grasp of the almost magical power of his art or his willingness to accept the cash tip that his father refused.
In any event, despite the quaint, pastoral setting of the opening sections, Together very definitely takes place in the New China, where art is all well and good, but ultimately it’s all about the money. The modern world comes crashing in soon enough, as Xiaochun and his father find themselves leaving their sleepy little village for Beijing, where the boy’s been invited to apply for admission to a prestigious music school.
Chen plays up the contrasts between the serene, contained beauty of the pair’s hometown and the daunting, barely comprehensible scale of Beijing, shooting the place to appear like an even bigger, more westernized city than it probably is. Sleek, impossibly tall buildings, signs written in English and women in short skirts and high heels dominate the new landscape, most of which looks like we’re experiencing it directly through Xiaochun’s hungry eyes. In fact, the boy’s first brush with modernity-made-human is in the form of a glamorous mystery woman spied shamelessly cavorting with her entrepreneur boyfriend, both of whom look like stylish refugees from some timelessly cool French New Wave film. Xiaochun is instantly mesmerized, but by the time he comes to his senses, the girl’s gone.
The melodrama of Together is slow to emerge, and details rather than plot points dominate the film for its first (and best) hour. After discovering that the music academy accepts only rich, well-connected students, Xiaochun’s dad finds him a private teacher, a disillusioned eccentric named Jiang (Wang Zhiwen) who lives in a messy, run-down apartment with a slew of badly behaved cats. Like most of the cranky, reclusive teachers you meet in movies, Jiang is also something of a genius, a closet idealist and romantic, and a strong bond soon forms between him and his new pupil.
Our young hero also reconnects with the mystery woman from his initial Beijing encounter, who turns out to be a smart and lovable but unlucky-in-love party girl named Lili (Chen Hong, the director’s real-life wife). Xiaochun begins forming strong relationships with both Jiang and Lili, even as his bumpkin father begins slipping away, becoming more and more of a minor character in the boy’s life (and, to some extent, in the film itself).
Before dear old dad completely slips away, though, he hooks up his son with a new teacher, realizing that the intensely competitive and corrupt music world requires a more prestigious and ambitious teacher to take a student all the way to the top. At this point, about midway through, the film makes a couple of almost simultaneous wrong turns, one of which amounts to an extended and nearly pointless detour in which Xiaochun loses his prize violin. Equally problematic is the overly abrupt jettisoning of Jiang and the almost instantaneous substitution of the Svengali-like new teacher, Professor Yu (played, interesting enough, by Chen Kaige himself).
Together begins treading water at this point, as the story begins flailing about in several directions, and more than a faint whiff of the maudlin begins to fill the air. The high-powered and slickly self-possessed Professor Yu takes the boy under his wing, becoming his mentor and remaking Xiaochun in his own image, as the boy’s real father slips even further out of the picture. It’s not quite clear how we’re supposed to feel about Yu or what he’s doing to his star pupil, but his position as a wedge driven between the boy and his father is clear as consommé.
Chen seems to lose control of the film during this last act, manufacturing crisis after crisis simply to provide some semblance of “action” and jumping through hoops to provide resolution where none is really needed. The grand finale is such wonderfully overblown melodrama that it actually works, but too much of what immediately precedes it just seems half-hearted and somewhat contrived storytelling. Enormous secrets are revealed (at the last minute, naturally) that don’t really do much to further the direction or shape of the film, and most of these wannabe bombshells just lie there. Chen piles on the courses, giving us everything he assumes will be required to satisfy us, but, in the end, just leaves us a bit hungry and wanting more.
Still, it all looks wonderful, the music is pretty darned glorious (a heady mix of Brahms, Tchaikovsky and Asian sounds), and, if the rising surge of sentimentalism doesn’t drag you under, Together is, for the most part, an extremely enjoyable experience. It’s a smaller, more personal sort of film than we’ve come to expect from the director of such epic, almost operatic works as Farewell, My Concubine and The Emperor and the Assassin, but Chen handles the intimacy with skill and grace.
Of course, there’s little in the movie’s somewhat soapy narrative to rival the wonderful individual images threaded throughout of daily life in Beijing, but I suppose we should just be thankful for a film so full of small favors. Even the handful of shots of the crowded Beijing train station might almost be a lost Lumiere Brothers short, shot in a parallel Chinese universe, and one could make a meal of that all by itself.
Film Critic Lance Goldenberg can be reached at lgoldenb@tampabay.rr.com or 813-248-8888 ext. 157.
This article appears in Jul 10-16, 2003.


