Progressive voters can be forgiven our delight in how Tampa’s mayoral election is turning out. The two most broadminded and forward-thinking candidates, Pam Iorio and Frank Sanchez, outpolled a field of more parochial politicians and are now engaged in a runoff. This is a choice that any smug editorialist can love.
Things could go wrong, of course.
Choose Pam for her sensible focus on good government, and wind up with an unambitious city, satisfied with solving problems (sort of) within the same parameters we always have.
Choose Frank for his activism in promoting economic development and international trade, and wind up wondering what he’s really up to and who will benefit.
Iorio is the safe choice.
Sanchez is the bold choice.
A female friend of mine didn’t accuse me of misogyny when I suggested a classic metaphor: If we voters are like a woman trying to choose between two prospective husbands, then Iorio is the husband we know would never cheat on us; we aren’t so sure about Sanchez, but, oh, what a tingle he gives.
Since the touch-screen I pressed on March 4 didn’t obligate my preference beyond that day, I reserve the right to change my mind on March 25.
So let’s review the differences.
Iorio has confined her campaign to issues directly under the mayor’s control, inside-the-government stuff like the efficiency of city services and the effect of regulation and taxing schemes on urban redevelopment. If elected mayor, no doubt she would be good at it.
Sanchez offers a more expansive vision of Tampa and its future, along with the mayor’s ability to influence it.
The question of whether there ought to be more international flights at Tampa International Airport may not interest most voters (which probably explains why Sanchez got only half as many votes as Iorio in the first election). But it illustrates a key difference in their approaches.
Drawing on his experience in marketing and international trade, Sanchez proposes a credible strategy for bringing various market forces together to increase air traffic between Tampa and Mexico, Tampa and the Dominican Republic, Tampa and Cuba. The entire city would benefit from this increased activity, not just the publicly owned airport, Sanchez says.
Skeptics — and Iorio isn’t the only one — say it’s all been tried before and the market just isn’t there. Iorio says she’ll leave these sorts of decisions to the airlines and the experts who run the airport, whom she admires.
I’m no aviation expert, but I score this one for Sanchez, just for trying.
For all of Iorio’s expertise in government, I also hear more specifics from Sanchez on issues such as how the city can stimulate residential development downtown, diversification and expansion at the port, and an economic transformation of the city’s poorest neighborhoods in east Tampa.
All are challenges that will have a long-term impact on the city, and not just because of the increased tax revenues that success would bring.
Sanchez also seems more appreciative of the ethnic diversity that has always shaped Tampa and is changing it still, without much notice from white people. He tells how an international bank was looking for Japanese speakers to work in one of its back-office processing centers in Tampa. It found them, not by looking in Seattle or San Francisco, but by posting a notice in an Asian grocery just north of downtown.
“We don’t see ourselves as an international city, and that’s part of our problem,” says Sanchez.
At the two candidates’ victory parties on March 4, it was Frank’s that had a richer variety of people. In other words, it looked more like Tampa.
Still, one wonders if Sanchez has all these good ideas, why he hasn’t accomplished more of them in the private sector. You don’t have to be mayor to set yourself up as a broker for international trade. Many voters would be more comfortable with Sanchez if he had a more visible local track record.
That’s where Iorio beats him in spades. We know what Iorio has accomplished because we’ve seen her for 18 years, first in a policy-making role on the County Commission, then in a manager’s role as Supervisor of Elections. If you’re looking at resumes, that’s a pretty good preparation for a mayor.
Iorio is a good planner, a good listener and a keeper of promises. Over the years she’s come up with some big ideas of her own, and except for some difficult ones like a long-range plan for mass transit, many of her big ideas came true.
Ask her how she wants to transform Tampa, however, and her answer is as unexciting as ice water. She wants Tampa to be known as a city whose governmental practices set a national standard for innovation and efficiency. In other words, we can move our city forward by getting it on the cover of Governing magazine.
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzz.
Sanchez scored points during last week’s prime-time television debate by seeming to be better prepared than Iorio on a number of specific issues. When Pam challenged Frank on the accuracy of his information, he retorted that he got it from the St. Petersburg Times, one of the sponsors of the evening’s debate.
The audience roared, but the next day Sanchez overplayed his hand. He tried to paint Iorio as a tax-happy liberal by citing a casual suggestion she made at a commission meeting 12 years ago. Once again, those of us who want to support him were left wondering about Frank’s judgment, his internal compass.
If Sanchez loses this election, and he probably will, it won’t be because he failed to go negative. It will be because he failed — when it mattered last fall, before Iorio entered the race — to articulate why all of us should want to live in the international city he envisions.
“We can do better,” he says sometimes. That slogan should have been plastered on billboards all over town last September.
Contact Editor Jim Harper at 813-248-8888, ext. 163, or e-mail him at jim.harper@weeklyplanet.com.
This article appears in Mar 19-25, 2003.

