
Maybe the best thing that can be said about The Jacket is that it belongs to a long, proud tradition of movies narrated by guys who turn out to be dead.
Seriously. Dead protagonists are part of a grand old cine-lineage dating back to some of the better film noirs of the ’40s and ’50s (so don’t let anyone tell you M. Night Shyamalan got there first) and fiddled with every few years in the form of some tasty but empty-caloried nugget like Carnival of Souls or any number of classic Twilight Zone episodes. Some of these movies actually take the brave and very un-Shyamalanian step of telling us right up front that our narrator’s a stiff (most famously, Sunset Boulevard), and The Jacket, at least at first glance, would seem to fit right in with that esteemed company.
Despite a promising beginning, however, The Jacket doesn’t do much to improve on the formula – unless you count teasing us with not just one but multiple deaths for its main character. “I was 27 the first time I died,” are the first words of our narrator, Jack Starks (Adrien Brody), who then proceeds to hedge his bets (and ours) by announcing that he didn’t exactly die – although, then again, maybe he did.
Jack’s not-quite-death is only the first in a series of deliberately cryptic head trips that divert our attention from the more ordinary aspects that ultimately dominate The Jacket, making what is essentially a run-of-the-mill thriller often seem like a case study in high concept ambiguity. The upside of this, of course, is that even if you hate the film, you may still have fun arguing about what it really “means.”
You can blame much of the vagueness on the fact that our narrator is about as unreliable as they come. For starters, Jack suffers from partial amnesia and possible psychological disorders resulting from a stint in the first Gulf War (the one fought under the reign of George I, back in ’91). Jack’s basically a good egg, though, a guy who just wants to do the right thing – only to have it blow up in his face, in the time-honored manner prescribed for all luckless noir protagonists. That’s literally what happens to him in the movie’s opening moments, as he offers a hand of friendship to a scared, baby-faced Iraqi kid who promptly pulls out a pistol and blows away part of Jack’s brain.
Everything that follows can be taken in any number of ways, although to these eyes it’s just a more or less straightforward sci-fi thriller (or as straightforward as a movie about time-travel paradoxes is likely to be). Other moviegoers might see The Jacket as the extended hallucination of a deranged mind, while more metaphysically inclined viewers might take the entire movie as the final flash of a consciousness being extinguished.
The movie’s storytelling methods deliberately mirror the fractured patterns of its narrator’s mind (with subliminal flash frames and jump cuts representing the crazily firing synapses of Jack’s brain), so it’s impossible to say for certain what we’re to make of all the very strange things that happen to our hero in the aftermath of his first “death.”
Shortly after the head wound incident, we find our narrator locked away in a Vermont loony bin for a murder that he can’t quite remember and may or may not have committed. Abused by sadistic attendants and subjected to ominous experiments by the creepy head shrink (Kris Kristofferson), Jack winds up shoved into an isolation-tank-like space. Duly confined, he suddenly finds himself leaping between the present and a future where he races against the clock to discover The Truth about his own life and death. In the process of all this temporal jumping-about, Jack also manages to find time for a little snuggling with a local waitress (Keira Knightley) living in a dump with lots of bad shag carpet and an extensive collection of Velvet Underground records.
There’s much to admire about The Jacket, at least during its ultra-mysterious early sections, when the film is all haunting visuals and foreboding, Gothic atmosphere. The plainly horrifying imagery of Jack being filed away in his cramped isolation space – a nondescript wall of barely coffin-sized morgue drawers – conjures up everything from Kafka to Cronenberg to concentration camp footage (with a bit of the Theatre of the Absurd and Phantasm thrown in for good measure), while the interludes with drooling inmates happily recall The Snake Pit and One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest. Director John Maybury is clearly a filmmaker who borrows from the best.
The movie The Jacket resembles most, though, for better and for worse, is Jacob’s Ladder, another film about an unhinged veteran of an unpleasant war (as opposed to the happy-go-lucky kind of war), haunted by demons that might be real and might be figments of his own messed-up mind.
Both movies trade in conspiracy theories, rampant paranoia, muddled metaphysics, temporal disorientation, barrages of ambient sound and the supremely seductive notion of latching on to an unpopular war as a metaphor for whatever ails ya. Substitute The Jacket‘s Gulf War for Jacob’s Ladder‘s Vietnam, and they could almost be the same semi-interesting movie.
Unfortunately, The Jacket could almost be any number of other movies, too, and when the film’s mysteries are eventually revealed, they’re simply not all that, well, mysterious. Ultimately, there’s precious little to ponder beyond some lushly creepy-crawly imagery adorning a disappointingly generic product.
Maybury basically takes one recycled item from column A (amnesiac hero struggling to piece together the puzzle of his own life), one from column B (character scurrying about in one time in order to affect events in another time), adds a dash of MSG (tasty visuals, hints of deeper meanings, a bit of romance) and invites us to chow down. The first tastes are tantalizing enough, but it’s soon apparent that these ingredients are somewhat less than fresh, and that there’s really not much here to stick to the ribs.
Lance.Goldenberg@weeklyplanet.com
This article appears in Mar 2-8, 2005.

