L to R: Matt Acquard (Jonah), Jenny Lester (Diana), Jackson Goldberg (Liam), Kate Berg (Melody) Credit: Joey Clay Photography

L to R: Kate Berg, Jackson Goldberg, Jenny Lester, Matt Acquard Credit: Photo by Beth Reynolds/American Stage Theatre

With a clickbait title that immediately provokes controversy and heated disagreements over the intended meaning, Bad Jews has arrived at American Stage in St. Petersburg. 

I don’t know. What’s a bad Jew? Monica Lewinsky? Bernie Madoff? Amy Winehouse? Anthony Weiner? How did they fail the legacy test and get relegated to that suspect category? I had a BLT. So what? I didn’t go home for Passover. Yeah, well, I can’t remember the answer to the four seder questions, either. No, I don’t want to visit Israel. Sure, I like shrimp teriyaki. OK, I’m dating a shiksa and getting a tattoo. So call me a bad Jew, already.

Joshua Harmon’s 2013 comedy of millennial Jews trying to understand (as in cope, discard, disprove, embrace, override, balance, all or none of the above) their obligation to their heritage has become one of the most popular, widely produced plays of the contemporary theater repertoire.

And one of the most vexed. Is it stereotyping? Is it self-hatred or just self-deprecating? Is it insightful? Is it true? Does it give reason for protesting or reason for celebrating? Why can’t we all just get along?

Whatever your feelings about the whole notion of a “bad Jew” or the depiction of the Jewish family on stage, this play, brilliantly and lovingly directed by Amy Resnick, is not to be missed. It’s full of energy, laughs, ample cringes, more than a few winces, frequent gasps, but with its share of tears too. 

Theater this provocative — as in, thought-provoking and as in, having someone poke their finger in your eye — must be experienced firsthand, sitting right there in the audience. This review, rave though it is, pales next to this production with its dazzling text, insightful direction and sterling cast. 

Fair warning — get your ticket now.

L to R: Matt Acquard (Jonah), Jenny Lester (Diana), Jackson Goldberg (Liam), Kate Berg (Melody) Credit: Joey Clay Photography

As the family gathers for their grandfather’s funeral, the three grandchildren, plus a shiksa girlfriend, confront just what it means to be Jewish in our time, what it means to hold on to the heritage of a Holocaust survivor and how to be a good Jew in the process. First cousins Diana (Jenny Lester), who prefers her uber-Hebrew name Daphna, and Jonah (Matt Acquard) await Jonah’s brother Liam (Jackson Goldberg), who definitely has rejected his Hebrew name Schlomo, with his girlfriend Melody (Kate Berg). It’s a contentious generation — millennials who may be more secular or culinary or ethnic Jews than strictly observant, religious ones — and the death of their beloved Poppy brings all those animosities and agendas to a seething and boiling temperature. 

Families often fight over heirlooms and whom the deceased loved the most. Here the argument is over a Chai, a Hebrew pendant celebrating life (pronounced somewhere between “hi” with a “hard h” and “ki”, as in the toast L’chaim — To life) that the grandfather hid in the concentration camp and is now to be passed on to the next generation. Diana deserves it because she’s the most observant, damn it! Liam, a secular sellout and proud mocking atheist, deserves it because he’s the oldest male cousin, damn it! Jonah doesn’t want it, and we learn later, has found his own way to claim his grandfather’s legacy. Melody has no claim to the Chai as she’s the outsider, dismissed by Diana as just a blonde girlfriend from Delaware whose family was probably responsible for slaughtering the indigenous tribes centuries ago.

That particular accusation is one of the mildest that Diana slings from her cruel, self-righteous, sanctimonious — and hilarious — mouth. Jonah, the mild-mannered cousin, is easily dominated by the raucous motormouth Diana. Melody as the sweet-natured, unsuspecting stranger in their midst is nowhere near prepared for Diana’s gatling-gun delivery. Together they watch in horror while fanatical Diana and the zealous Liam self-destruct in a frenzied attack and counter-attack of all things Jewish. As one observer commented, they fight like Talmudic junkyard dogs!

Jackson Goldberg, Kate Berg, Jenny Lester and Matt Acquard. Credit: Photo by Beth Reynolds/American Stage Theatre

For sure, Liam and Daphna have all the curtain-chewing interactions and monologues — OK, there are no curtains here in this multimillion dollar Upper West Side Manhattan studio apartment, just a Hudson River view and granite countertops. Ultimately, though, it’s Jonah and Melody who find a middle way through all these dynamics, and they bring a needed touch of humility and humanity to the scorched-earth proceedings. After all that primal screaming, Jonah’s final gesture turns our laughter into tears.

Does this sound like your family, Jewish or not? I overheard more than one comment at the end of the play, as men and women went to their separate restrooms, “she sounds like your cousin” and “that’s exactly what happened in New Rochelle” and “I told you so.” Here’s a classic example of the particular becoming the universal as happy families are all alike, but unhappy families… well, you know the rest.

There’s an entire panoply of bad Jews here, or at least Jews acting badly with one another, as they reckon with just how to make sense of their history, tradition, religion, legacy. It’s sometimes said “two Jews, three opinions,” so get yourself to this production at American Stage and be a part of the debate.

Ben Wiley is a retired professor of film and literature at St. Petersburg College. He also was on staff in the Study Abroad Office at University of South Florida as statewide Director of the Florida Consortium/University of Cambridge (UK) International Summer Schools. His interests are in film, books, theatre, travel, literacy programs, kayaking Florida rivers. Contact him here.

%{[ data-embed-type="image" data-embed-id="59a99bae38ab46e8230492c5" data-embed-element="span" data-embed-size="640w" contenteditable="false" ]}%Ben Wiley is a retired professor of FILM and LITERATURE...