Jackson McMillan at WMNF 88.5-FM in Tampa, Florida on April 4, 2025. Credit: Photo by Ray Roa

As reports of big fundraising numbers emerged leading into last week’s special congressional elections in Florida, Democratic political consultants from around the state took aim at the young man helping to bring in that bounty —23-year-old St. Petersburg political strategist Jackson McMillan.

The criticism was based on the fact that the seats in Florida Congressional District 1 and District 6 were considered unattainable for Democrats—Donald Trump and the then-incumbent Republicans who ran in those districts in November won by more than 30 percentage points.

“Were these races ever winnable? My answer is absolutely,” McMillan told this reporter on WMNF-88.5 FM on Friday morning.

“Our polling internally on the Josh Weil campaign matched the White House’s lead pollster that came out just a week before Election Day, so when my polling number that my firm ran matched Tony Fabrizio’s, I was like, I must be doing something right.”

An internal poll conducted by Trump pollster Fabrizio did show Democrat Josh Weil with a lead over Republican Randy Fine in CD 6. Another survey from St. Pete Polls in the week leading up to the election showed Fine up by just four points, 48%-44%.

Fine ended up defeating Weil by 14 points on Election Day. Republican Jimmy Patronis defeated Democrat Gay Valimont in CD 1 by 15 points.

The two Democrats raised more that $20 million in their campaigns, 90% of it from outside of Florida, McMillan says. Some fellow Democratic strategists contend that while McMillan and his firm Key Lime Strategies help raise a lot of awareness about the races, in the end his candidates still lost by double digits.

They question whether it was appropriate to tell Democratic donors that their contributions could help narrow the GOP’s numeric advantage in Congress.

“We had no business telling donors we were going to win those seats. That was a straight-up lie,” said Orlando based Democratic strategist Chris Mitchell with Statecraft Digital said last Friday on WMNF.

“We’ve now heard the last three days the Florida Democratic Party and others take victory laps on losing by double-digits, and that is not how we build long, systemic infrastructure in the state, and that’s not how we produce long-term outcomes,” Mitchell said.

Campaign finance records from the Weil and Valimont campaigns in mid-March showed that they had paid Key Lime Strategies $4.7 million, more than one third their total spending.

McMillan says that “it costs money to make money,” with much of those funds going to pay for fund-raising ads.

He also noted that the campaigns received nothing from the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee and not that much from the Democratic National Committee. He appreciates what the Florida Democratic Party was able to contribute, but says “it was a drop in the bucket of the money that we pulled in from around the country, and it costs money to solicit that money. It costs money to text. It costs money to send emails.”

McMillan boasts about his transparency, saying that his fee structure is transparent on his firm’s website. But that transparency only goes so far, as he will not disclose how much profit his firm will ultimately make from working on the Weil and Valimont campaigns.

“It was certainly not millions of dollars,” he said in a phone conversation on Saturday. “I don’t want to give you a figure because it might be incorrect.”

‘I’m done dealing with these a—’

As Florida Democrats’ electoral hopes have deteriorated in recent election cycles, the consulting class has been subject to escalating attacks.

“People like Jackson McMillan are the exact type of consultants who people say are the problem in our party,” said Democratic National Committee Vice Chair David Hogg in a social media posting last month.

“I’m done dealing with these a— and it’s time they start being called out. Everyone says f— the consultants but won’t name names. Jackson is one of many.” [Elisions by the Phoenix.]

Hogg was responding to New York Democratic U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s comment that footage taken from a 92-minute Instagram Live presentation she gave on Feb. 3 for an ad boosting Valimont and Weil was being used without her consent. McMillan then took down the ad immediately.

Another incident that has rankled some is the contention that he worked for a candidate for St. Petersburg City Council last year who he knew didn’t live within the city limits. He denies that he knew that.

The candidate, Juan Lopez Estevez, was endorsed by former St. Petersburg Mayor Rick Kriseman and former Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn in the open District 3 race. Estevez finished fourth in the Aug. 20 primary election.

“To my knowledge, Juan was living at his mother’s house,” McMillan said over the weekend. “He told me he lived in St. Petersburg. At no point did I ever have any reason to believe that Juan didn’t live on Cherry street. It was only after accusations started flying after the campaign was over that I had any real inclination. I’ve heard the rumors, but I don’t have anything to substantiate that.”

However, the Rev. Andy Oliver, the pastor of the Allendale United Methodist Church in St. Petersburg, said that he spoke with McMillan on Friday as both left the radio station where they had just appeared as guests. Oliver was supporting another candidate in the race, Nick Carey, who he thought might have made the runoff if it hadn’t been for Estevez’s participation.

“I said listen, ‘I am still very angry with you … because you knowingly ran a candidate that did not live in the district,’” Oliver said.

“In that conversation, he admitted to me that he knew that Juan didn’t live in the district. He said, ‘He was there for two months,’ and that to me was even more telling.” The St. Petersburg charter states that a candidate for city council must be a resident of the declared district for at least 12 months as of the date of the primary election.

“At one point, he laughed and said, ‘Of course, he didn’t live there.’ And so Jackson admitted that he knew that Juan did not live in the district. His reasons for doing that are that he had a company to support and Gen Z people on his team that needed to be paid.”

“I’m not sure what the pastor is referring to,” McMillan said when told of Oliver’s recollection of their discussion. “I remember a piece of the conversation discussing the voter registration of Juan’s father who shares a name with him was originally used as ‘proof’ that Juan didn’t live in the district, because Juan’s father is registered in Tampa. I found that deeply comedic, because any amount of investigation would have revealed that it was Juan’s father. Perhaps a remark was misunderstood.”

For his part, Estevez insists the rumor that he didn’t reside in St. Petersburg “is 100% false.”

“If anyone had challenged my eligibility based on my residency, not only would they have been unsuccessful, but they would have been subjected to legal action as well,” he said in a text message.


Praise from the candidates

While he’s taking some licks, both Weil and Valimont are effusive in praising McMillan’s work in the special elections.

“Jackson McMillan took a teacher with no public profile and raised $15M in small dollars—unheard of for a Florida candidate, even for an elected official,” Weil told the Phoenix in email.

“The payments to Key Lime Strategies you see on our FEC report include all the costs of building and managing what would ultimately become one of the largest donor networks in the country, which includes all of the paid comms overhead for messaging via email, text, and social media over 4 months, all of our mailers, and all of our polling.

“We executed a plan built to deliver 90k votes that would be successful up to 40% voter turnout. Nobody outside of our team believed at any point along the way the turnout would even come close to that number, and ultimately it exceeded it. The work he did on this campaign should cement Jackson McMillan as the gold standard for Dem fundraising and political coordination in the state of Florida for years to come. There is nobody else in this state who could have produced anything close to what he did here in District 6 these last four months.”

Valimont also praised McMillan in a statement.

“Our campaign was powered by an average donation of just $32, proving that grassroots support can drive monumental change. For the first time in decades, we established a foundation for Democrats in the Panhandle, building infrastructure that will strengthen traditionally red areas for years to come.

“I want to recognize Jackson McMillan and the staff of Key Lime Strategies for their incredible work, which has laid the groundwork for continued progress in this area. The money invested in this race helped re-enroll thousands of Democrats in vote-by-mail and boosted voter registration efforts that would never have garnered any investment under normal circumstances. This campaign was always about more than just one race—it was about building a movement for lasting change.

“This race demonstrates that strategic investment in deep red districts, centered on fieldwork and direct voter engagement, can create meaningful shifts for Democrats as we head into the pivotal 2026 midterms. Our campaign is dedicated to sustaining this progress by allocating $170K to strengthen Democratic infrastructure in FL-01, ensuring the strides we’ve made continue to flourish. These organizations, including each county’s Democratic Executive Committee and Black Caucus, have championed Panhandle Democrats long before our campaign, stood with us for 20 months, and we’re excited to see the momentum they will build in the future.”

‘Jackson was a lifeline’

Among the winning candidates McMillan has worked are Tampa City Council members Lynn Hurtak and Bill Carlson. Hurtak declined to comment, while Carlson did not return a request for comment.

Kelly Johnson, who worked with McMillan on two unsuccessful campaigns for state House in Pinellas County over the past five years, praised his work.

“When I ran in 2020 against the incoming speaker of the House [Chris Sprawls], I was a new person in the political arena and Jackson was a lifeline for the entire campaign,” she said in a text message. “He was able to secure meetings and interviews and lead every single of our campaign meetings. At the time I did have a lot of television coverage and media coverage, which was amazing.”

While political analysts around the country continue to assess whether the margins of the two congressional races will ultimately mean anything in 2026, Mitchell fears that the tactics employed to raise so much campaign cash in districts that were so Republican leaning could hurt the Democrats in the future.

“Imagine if this was in CD-13 in Pinellas County in a special election where we could win that race, right?” he said, referring to the congressional district where Republican Anna Paulina Luna won by 10 points last fall. “They’re not likely to give as much or give next time, so I think that is the bigger thing we need to focus on.”

Florida Phoenix is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Florida Phoenix maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Michael Moline for questions: info@floridaphoenix.com.

Subscribe to Creative Loafing newsletters.

Follow us: Google News | NewsBreak | Reddit | Instagram | Facebook | BlueSky

Related Stories