Astra Pizza

A lot of Bay area pizza restaurants— “pizzerias” if we’re talking New Yawk—have claimed to offer New York pizza over the years. Few have delivered. This tiny place (pickup and delivery only) in a tiny, weathered strip mall nails it. The pies are gooey but not (too) greasy. The crust is thin and just a bit chewy, rather than crispy, allowing you to fold a slice like Travolta strutting Brooklyn in “Saturday Night Fever.” The sauce and cheese meld just right. The owner, Carlos, who’s from New Jersey, makes his own dough from scratch and gets some of his ingredients from up north. Open the box and one inhale tells you this pizza is scrumptiously Big Apple. astrapizzamenu.com —Eric Snider

See all winners from Best of the Bay 2020.