
In The Incredible Hulk, as in American History X and Fight Club, Edward Norton once again plays a pissed-off male who lashes out at everything in his path because it’s the only thing he knows how to do. There’s always an audience for movies about guys venting their anger in extreme ways, just as there will always be an audience for movies about women who like to shop, because men are apparently from Mars, women are from somewhere else, and art imitates life, even in popcorn flicks like The Incredible Hulk or Sex and the City, where critical evaluations like “good” or “bad” barely hold water with the true believers.
For those who may be unfamiliar with Marvel Comics’ green-skinned man’s man, the Hulk is rage personified — a towering, pea-brained inferno who bubbles up from the depths of mild-mannered Bruce Banner (Norton) whenever BB begins to get agitated — and The Incredible Hulk‘s most salient feature is surely the heaps of unfiltered aggression it offers audiences like holy communion. Gone are the moody convolutions and Oedipal mumbo-jumbo of Ang Lee’s poorly received 2003 Hulk, and in its place we have nearly two hours of pure id, a stripped-down (but not completely dumbed-down) take on Fight Club‘s fixation on guys pummeling each other, right down to the protag’s passive-aggressive split personality.
The Incredible Hulk is the latest in this summer’s lineup of likely blockbusters with gazillion-dollar budgets, but there’s something refreshingly frill-free about the way the movie cuts to the chase, beginning with an opening title sequence that presents its character’s origin story in just a few iconic images, the assumption presumably being that we’re either already familiar with the mythology or are capable of quickly catching on. (The movie also assumes our pop culture savvy, supplying sly nods to past Hulks Lou Ferrigno and Bill Bixby, as well as the obligatory cameo from Marvel head honcho Stan Lee.)
It’s all pretty straightforward but with a visceral appeal and a forward momentum that any summer blockbuster would envy. The movie begins in the densely populated tangle of a Brazilian slum where Banner hides from the U.S. military (who seek to dissect and weaponize him) and then spends most of its time simply following him on the run, as Norton alternates between brooding about his fate (something at which this gifted actor excels) and transforming into a roaring, 10-foot juggernaut smashing everything that gets in his way. This isn’t exactly one of the more sophisticated narratives you’ll encounter this season, but the sound and fury can be seductive.
Curiously, the movie’s biggest problem is the subpar CGI work that brings the Hulk to life. In an era when computers can create something as inspiring as Peter Jackson’s King Kong (still Hollywood’s most believable CGI creature), we expect more of our super-entities than a flatly drawn steroid casualty resembling nothing so much as a big green penis. Thankfully, director Louis Leterrier chooses to shoot mostly in a half-light that minimizes design flaws, and by the time we get to the final showdown between Norton’s emerald alter-ego and an even bigger, meaner adversary, we can almost believe it when the movie’s resident nerd starts calling Hulkie “Beautiful” and “God-like.”
The power of suggestion, like rage, is a potent thing. Hulk might essentially be a combination of unchecked hormones and unlimited strength that speaks directly to adolescent boys, but by the end of the movie, he’s oozing a raw power that even the Sex and the City girls might find irresistible.
There are also plenty of passions at play this week in Before the Rains, but in some ways this Merchant/Ivory-approved arthouse opus might be even less convincing than The Incredible Hulk. Before the Rains is filled with stunning landscapes and handsome period costumes, with expert cinematography that makes even the most mundane objects sparkle like the artificial dirt at Disney’s Animal Kingdom. It’s all as pretty as a picture and often just as flat.
The film takes place in 1937 in the Kerala region of India, where the bottoms of the locals’ feet are never dirty despite everyone walking around barefoot all day. It’s that kind of movie. It’s also the kind of movie where we know beyond the shadow of a doubt that the gun so meaningfully presented by one man to another in Act 1 will absolutely, positively be used in ways that will change everyone’s life by Act 3 — especially since the characters are friends representing mutually exclusive historical forces on an inevitable collision course.
The man with the gun is Henry Moores (Linus Roache), a British plantation owner who doesn’t understand all the fuss over colonialism, since all he wants to do is build schools, hospitals and a road to transport spices across India. “Today tea, tomorrow cinnamon,” crows this self-described “man of the future,” a benevolent dictator who sincerely loves India, even as he snags, depletes and discards her resources. To drive home its point, Before the Rains supplies Henry with an Indian mistress, who is also his married housemaid and with whom he engages in splendiferous and utterly antiseptic sex under cascading waterfalls. The beads of sweat carefully deposited on the characters’ bodies look lovely but not at all earned.
The movie sets up its conflicts, plies us with symbolism and repressed emotions, then trudges dutifully toward its resolution, eventually leading a mob of torch-wielding villagers right up to the master’s doorstep. It all ends in a quaintly old-fashioned wave of crime and punishment before those titular rains arrive to wash away everyone’s sins.
This article appears in Jun 18-24, 2008.

