Pumpkin Cheese Pie with Toffee and Caramel Swirl (aka Serendipity Pie)

It all started with some very disappointing sugar cookies that had I made. They were the refrigerator kind that come ready to bake My daughter sneaked them into my cart at the supermarket and I never even noticed them until I got home. Since I had them, I decided to pop them in the oven for a quick snack. They were awful! The cookies spread into flat, sugary pancakes that all ran into each other. Not good at all! I hated to just throw them away, so I stuck them in a zip lock bag, hoping that I might find a use for them later.

A few days later, I ended up with some leftover pumpkin puree from another recipe. After twirling some ideas around in my head, I decided to mix my leftover pumpkin with cream cheese, cinnamon, nutmeg and ginger to make a pie. I already had the ingredients needed for the filling, so all I needed to do was figure out what to use for the crust. That was when I had my “Eureka!” moment. The sugar cookies! It was brilliant!

I tossed those cookies into the food processor with a touch of cinnamon and salt, and pulverized them into crumbs. Then, I mixed in some melted butter and voila! Pie crust!

To take the pie up a notch, I mixed in some toffee bits that were hanging around and swirled globs of dulce de leche all through it. I also spread a layer of dulce de leche on top of the pie and piped little dulce de leche rosettes all around the perimeter, you know, just to make it pretty.


Let me tell you, this pie was To. Die. For. Seriously! The filling was oh, so rich and creamy, with gorgeous, thick caramel ribbons running through it. The toffee bits added a just a little bit of crunch. And the crust? Well, the crust worked out beautifully. It tasted great, yet it didn’t interfere with the other flavors in the pie. You could certainly use a traditional graham cracker crust or any kind of cookie crumbs you like. If I hadn’t had the sugar cookies, I probably would have tried this with ginger snaps.

Pumpkin Cheese Pie with Toffee and Caramel Swirl (aka Serendipity Pie)

(Printable Recipe)


For the crust:

3 cups sugar cookie crumbs (pulverize 6-8 large sugar cookies in the food processor)

1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon

6 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted

For the filling:

2 8-ounce packages of cream cheese, softened

2/3 cup sugar ( Use more or less according to your taste)

1 cup canned pumpkin puree  (not pumpkin pie filling)

1 teaspoon ground cinnamon

1/4 teaspoon ground ginger

1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg

1/2 cup toffee bits

2 cups dulce de leche or caramel sauce of your choice, divided. (You may have to soften the dulce de leche to make it “swirlable” by microwaving it on 50% power for about 15 seconds.)


For the crust:

In a medium bowl, mix cookie crumbs, cinnamon and melted butter until well blended. Press mixture into a 9-inch pie plate.

Bake at 350 degrees F for 10 minutes. Cool.

For the filling:

Beat cream cheese and sugar together on medium speed until fluffy, about 2 minutes. Add pumpkin, cinnamon, ginger and nutmeg and beat until completely combined.

Mix in the toffee bits and swirl in 1 cup of the dulce de leche or caramel sauce.

Pour the filling into the pie crust and smooth it out.  Refrigerate until firm, about 4 hours.

Carefully spread the second cup of softened dulce de leche or caramel sauce evenly over the top of the pie.

If desired, use another 1/2 cup of dulce de leche to pipe rosettes or other design on top of the pie, using a pastry bag and a medium tip, (like an Ateco #843).

Chill until the topping is firm.


Still hungry?  Come visit me at Sticky, Gooey, Creamy, Chewy, or follow me on Twitter.

Have you ever noticed that the most exciting inventions and breakthrough discoveries are sometimes stumbled upon purely by accident? From medical research, to science and technology right on down to recipes, some of our biggest boo boos can be and have been turned into “Eureka!” moments. For example, the discoveries of penicillin, quinine, the smallpox vaccine and even x-rays were all the happened upon by accident. Indispensable innovations like the microwave, the pacemaker, the computer mouse and even Post-Its were invented by chance.

So then, what about serendipity in the kitchen? Many of you might be familiar with the story of Ruth Wakefield, the inventor of the original chocolate chip cookie. In the 1930s, Ruth and her husband owned the Toll House Inn in Massachusetts. One evening in 1937, she was making butter cookies for her guests and thought she would make them all chocolate instead. She cut a bar of chocolate into tiny pieces and added them to the cookie dough, thinking that the chocolate would melt completely, giving her chocolate butter cookies. When the cookies came out of the oven, the chocolate hadn’t melted at all! Instead, the “chocolate chips” had kept their form. Thus, the Toll House chocolate chip cookie was born and went on to become the most popular and well-known cookie of all time!

I’ve certainly had my share of culinary flops that I was able to transform into some pretty terrific recipes. This decadent and devastatingly delicious Pumpkin Cheese Pie with Toffee and Caramel Swirl is a perfect example. Let me tell you how it came to be.

Scroll to read more Food News articles
Join the Creative Loafing Tampa Bay Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state.
Help us keep this coverage going with a one-time donation or an ongoing membership pledge.


Join Creative Loafing Tampa Bay Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.

We welcome readers to submit letters regarding articles and content in Creative Loafing Tampa Bay. Letters should be a minimum of 150 words, refer to content that has appeared on Creative Loafing Tampa Bay, and must include the writer's full name, address, and phone number for verification purposes. No attachments will be considered. Writers of letters selected for publication will be notified via email. Letters may be edited and shortened for space.

Email us at [email protected]