'You can't manufacture facts': Hillsborough deputies can't get story straight in Andrew Joseph III trial

HCSO officers and legal team told conflicting stories today at the federal trial.

During the second day of the federal trial for the wrongful death of Andrew Joseph III, Hillsborough County Sheriff Deputies and lawyers contradicted themselves.

The discrepancies in their stories were so obvious that they led judge Mary Scriven to tell HCSO’s defense team, “You can’t manufacture facts.”

Deputies involved in Joseph’s detainment and ejection from the 2014 Florida State Fair told differing stories under oath. Now-retired Corporal Mark Clark was the commanding officer at the fair on student night when Joseph was ejected by HCSO before being struck by a car and dying.

Clark is the only officer named in the lawsuit, which seeks $30 million in damages. The Florida State Fair Authority already made a monetary settlement in the case, the Joseph family told Creative Loafing Tampa Bay.

While on the stand, Clark told the courtroom he “can’t recall” if he had detained Joseph that night on the midway. Whenever he was questioned at all about detaining the 14-year-old, he stuck to that story. But an HCSO detention record from that night said that Clark was the detaining officer.

On the form it said that Joseph was, “Running through the midway causing disorderly conduct.” The midway is the main area of the fair, where many of the attractions and food vendors are located. 

Running is not disorderly conduct, as the plaintiffs pointed out. Clark agreed. But the defense said the midway area of the fair could often be crowded, in an attempt to paint running as disorderly conduct.

Despite Clark’s claims about not remembering Joseph, he did recall arresting a 15-year-old who was smoking a hand-rolled cigarette. He confirmed that the cigarette was filled with tobacco—which should only warrant a citation—but still arrested the kid who was charged with a misdemeanor.

However, the officer who worked under Clark, Henry Echenique, testified that he clearly remembers Clark handing over Joseph and telling him to eject the child from the fair.

“He told me to fill out the ejection form,” Echenique told the court, which included a 10-person jury with no Black people. “He said he was busy with something else.”

Echenique said Clark told him that the child was causing disorderly conduct.

While Joseph was detained for about 30-40 minutes before being put in a van and driven off the fairgrounds, Echenique said that he told Clark that Joseph wanted to speak with him, but that Clark refused.

To demonstrate that Joseph had a chance to call for help, the defense for HCSO used cell phone call logs which they said show the recent middle school grad making several calls during the time that he was detained.

But the family is not responsible for the detaining and ejection of Joseph, the plaintiffs pointed out.

Hillsborough Deputy Steven Jones drove Joseph away from the fair to a dark spot on Orient Road, about 100 yards south of I-4. Joseph tried to cross the interstate, and was hit by the SUV that killed him.

Jones initially testified that the area he dropped Joseph and others off at was lit, but the plaintiffs brought up a deposition from 2017 in which Jones said he did not recall the area having lights.

Following the three officers’ testimony, Judge Scriven dismissed the jury for the day.

When the jurors left, she addressed the HCSO defense team.

She mentioned that a stipulation, or pre-trial agreement, between the plaintiffs and defense clearly said that Clark detained Joseph at the midway and then led him to the HCSO detention area. Scriven then pointed out that in the courtroom, the defense changed its story to say that Clark “escorted” Joseph to the area.

Several members of the defense team argued that it had come to their attention that because Clark couldn’t remember if he had detained Joseph, that it might have been another officer who detained the teen and handed him to Clark.

“Who is this mystery officer?” Scriven asked the defense.

She wondered if the mystery officer could show up to testify and support the defense’s claims, adding that Clark never testified about another officer who detained Joseph.

“You can’t manufacture facts,” she told the defense.

The trial continues tomorrow, Sept. 14 at 9 a.m. and is expected to run until Sept. 22.

About The Author

Justin Garcia

Justin Garcia previously wrote for the USA Today Network, The Economic Hardship Reporting Project, Scalawag Magazine, and various other news outlets. When he's not writing, Justin likes to make music, read, play basketball and spend time with loved ones. 

Scroll to read more Tampa Bay News articles
Join the Creative Loafing Tampa Bay Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state.
Help us keep this coverage going with a one-time donation or an ongoing membership pledge.


Join Creative Loafing Tampa Bay Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.

We welcome readers to submit letters regarding articles and content in Creative Loafing Tampa Bay. Letters should be a minimum of 150 words, refer to content that has appeared on Creative Loafing Tampa Bay, and must include the writer's full name, address, and phone number for verification purposes. No attachments will be considered. Writers of letters selected for publication will be notified via email. Letters may be edited and shortened for space.

Email us at [email protected]