February 14, 2020

25 essential pizza restaurants in Tampa Bay you should've tried by now

While we may not be known for pizza, Tampa Bay is rich in legit slices. Whether you're just looking for delivery on a lazy night after work, or a place to chow down after you leave the clubs in Ybor, here are a few must-try za spots.

Scroll down to view images
Cappy’s Pizza  
Multiple locations
Soul-warming NYC- and Chicago-style pies are served up in this pizzeria’s homey digs. The Cappy and The Veggie are its signature creations, and every location has its own special qualities.
Photo via Cappy’s Pizza/Facebook

Cappy’s Pizza

Multiple locations
Soul-warming NYC- and Chicago-style pies are served up in this pizzeria’s homey digs. The Cappy and The Veggie are its signature creations, and every location has its own special qualities.

Photo via Cappy’s Pizza/Facebook
Corner’s Pizza  
615 Channelside Dr, Space #9, Tampa
This walk-up window joint has outdoor seating and a simple menu. The square pizzas make it a corner-piece-lover’s paradise.
Photo via The Corners Pizza?Facebook

Corner’s Pizza

615 Channelside Dr, Space #9, Tampa
This walk-up window joint has outdoor seating and a simple menu. The square pizzas make it a corner-piece-lover’s paradise.

Photo via The Corners Pizza?Facebook
New York New York Pizza  
1512 E. Seventh Ave. Tampa
A street-side pizzeria that provides huge, deliciously greasy slices inside and from a walk-up window. Don’t forget garlic knots, too. The Ybor location on Seventh Avenue is the OG, but there's a SoHo location for drunk MacDinton's nights.
Photo via New York New York/ Facebook

New York New York Pizza

1512 E. Seventh Ave. Tampa
A street-side pizzeria that provides huge, deliciously greasy slices inside and from a walk-up window. Don’t forget garlic knots, too. The Ybor location on Seventh Avenue is the OG, but there's a SoHo location for drunk MacDinton's nights.

Photo via New York New York/ Facebook
Eddie and Sam’s Pizza  
203 E. Twiggs St., Tampa
This Italian joint creates its pies with NYC water. More than 20 toppings can dress your slice of choice, and something tells us the other grub is just as killer.
Photo via Eddie and Sam’s Pizza/Facebook

Eddie and Sam’s Pizza

203 E. Twiggs St., Tampa
This Italian joint creates its pies with NYC water. More than 20 toppings can dress your slice of choice, and something tells us the other grub is just as killer.

Photo via Eddie and Sam’s Pizza/Facebook
Crafty Squirrel  
259 Central Ave., St. Petersburg
Pizza, mac 'n' cheese, wings & loaded fries served with drinks in pitchers & teapots until late.
Photo via Crafty Squirrel/Facebook

Crafty Squirrel

259 Central Ave., St. Petersburg
Pizza, mac 'n' cheese, wings & loaded fries served with drinks in pitchers & teapots until late.

Photo via Crafty Squirrel/Facebook

Join the Creative Loafing Tampa Bay Press Club

At a time when local-based reporting is critical, support from our readers is essential to our future.