August 25, 2021

'Pretty Joe Rock,' one of Florida's rare private islands, is now on the market

It may be a tiny shack on an island, but it could be your tiny shack on an island. Right now, Sea Shell Key, also known as "Pretty Joe Rock," is currently on the market in the Florida Keys.

Located at 1 Pretty Joe Rock, in Marathon, the private, quarter-of-an-acre island is currently used as a vacation rental, and was once featured on HGTV's "Buying the Beach."  The 1,006-square-foot home comes with two-bedrooms and two-bathrooms, as well as three decks, an easement for access and parking, a deep water dock, and zero neighbors.

The island is also but fully capable of building pretty much whatever you want on it, since it's connected with shore electricity, and city water.

Pretty Joe Rock is currently asking $2,500,000 and the listing agent is Gidget Jackson of Re/Max Realty Group.

Photos via TripAdvisor/Zillow 

Join the Creative Loafing Tampa Bay Press Club

At a time when local-based reporting is critical, support from our readers is essential to our future.


'Pretty Joe Rock,' one of Florida's rare private islands, is now on the market
CL Staff

'Pretty Joe Rock,' one of Florida's rare private islands, is now on the market
CL Staff

'Pretty Joe Rock,' one of Florida's rare private islands, is now on the market
CL Staff

'Pretty Joe Rock,' one of Florida's rare private islands, is now on the market
CL Staff

'Pretty Joe Rock,' one of Florida's rare private islands, is now on the market
CL Staff