CL recently had the opportunity to talk with Michael Noer, director of the newly released Papillon, a reconsideration of the classic 1978 film with Steve McQueen and Dustin Hoffman.
Noer previously has made shorts and documentaries, plus feature films R (2010, prison drama), Northwest (2013, gang members in Copenhagen), Key House Mirror (2015, elderly love) and Nelly (period film to premiere in January, 2019).
He brings a European perspective (he’s Danish) to this iconic American film, this time with Charlie Hunnam as Henri “Papillon” Charrière and Rami Malek as Louis Dega. Papillon is a French safecracker, unjustly imprisoned in the brutal conditions of Devil’s Island penal colony in French Guiana, who forms an unlikely alliance with a forger, Louis Dega. Together, they conspire to survive the brutal and inhumane conditions of this hellhole.
This 2018 production is a massive directorial undertaking, even more so with the pressures and presumptions of tackling a “remake” of an iconic film everybody loves. CL had lots of questions, but here are seven. The interview was recorded, and Michael Noer’s answers are edited for clarity and space.
Is this a remake? Update? Reconsideration? What would you call it?
Critics and audiences can look at it how they want, but after they finish watching it, I hope they will think they have watched an “experience,” whether they like it or not. But for me as an artist, you have to go through so much torment and pain — not to compare myself with someone who is part of a prison colony — there’s just not enough energy to try to see if you think you can make a remake. I had to find at the core of my heart what I felt was the essence of the story. What kept me going was that I considered it a film about love and friendship, and a film about two guys who are initially extremely different but create an unbreakable bond that goes beyond life and death, goes beyond the prison system. I never really looked back at any point. I looked into the books, but I never felt the long shadows of the older film. I really felt that at the moment Charlie and Rami took on this endeavor themselves, the story just materialized as is. For any artist, you always have to find a way of getting out of the shadows of Shakespeare, or whatever you’re doing, or you’ll otherwise never find fuel enough to get you through the tough days.
And there were plenty of tough days, I would imagine. You had a cast of dozens, crew of hundreds, 5000 extras, multiple far-flung locations, weather difficulties, language barriers, an actor, Charlie Hunnam, who tries the method acting, losing 40 pounds and isolating himself for weeks in order to become “Papillon.” How did you make all that work?
Well, it’s so funny when you sum it all up like that. It reminds me — you’re absolutely right, that’s all the stuff we actually went through — sometimes one forgets all these things. That’s probably why one decides to have another kid or make another movie because you kind of forget how tough it is as well. It’s a salute to the story, to the character, to the book that got us through it all. Even though it was a huge logistical challenge with massive exterior sets that had to be built, it almost felt like the kind of movies that Hollywood doesn’t make anymore, which in itself was an interesting endeavor and great for me to do.
But what really kept us going again is the simplicity of the plot and the story, and also a chance for me to revisit a genre which I love. My debut film was a prison movie [R], so making Papillon was kind of like the mother of all prison movies. My debut film is stripped of anything unrealistic, anything near magical. It’s very bleak, extremely dark, almost no dialogue, they don’t even dream of escaping because it will never be possible. Now Papillon is the antithesis of that. It was really great to have a chance to revisit a genre I know and love, but do it in a completely different way, and yet tough to have all these locations and extras and everything. As tough as it is, making movies is great. I grew up alone with my mom in a small city, way, way outside of Copenhagen, so I have to pinch my arm all day to tell myself that, hey, I am in the movie business.

Even though it’s a story that’s brutal, you managed to find humor and humanity and grace. Still, I wonder, is Hollywood ready for something this grim? The original 1978 version certainly was too but I think you’ve notched it up into something, if I may say so, muddier and bloodier. Is the audience ready for something like this?
I think that’s why the producers in many ways, funnily enough, chose this Danish director who’d done these smaller, hopefully well-acted films, but they actually looked beyond the capability of asking whether he can tackle a thousand extras. I don’t think that was their worry. They actually saw strength in what is my main objective, which is trying to create character and drama. And I am really happy that you see that there is humor and interaction and connection between the characters as well. I really felt that is also at the core of this film, not from a logistic point of view but from a humanistic point of view. It’s important that there are these contradictory characters like Papillon and Dega, and it’s with their contradictions that you laugh and hopefully cry, but you also fear, and you are excited.
As for Hollywood and the audience being ready, oh, I mean, when is anyone ever ready for anything? The weird thing about film is that it’s almost trying to make a butterfly that has no wings. It’s a miracle of a kind because we’re actually doing a product that no one is asking for, then after that, we’re telling people to go and watch it. That’s actually what’s so amazing. For me, I don’t worry so much or think about if [an] audience is ready, but more I felt that the time was mature to revisit a story which to this day is as relevant as ever. Actually I look not so much to the readiness but more the relevance. And I think the relevance is still high.
And since you bring up your own Danish heritage, of course, I have to think of your homegrown philosopher Søren Kierkegaard and all of his notions of alienation and the absurd and existential survival. Was that at work in your outlook on life and in your making this movie?
I think you’re absolutely right. But I think it’s also about looking at life as something that’s progressing, and also looking at your own life in progression. Because of your question, I also have to say it’s so funny to look at my debut film R which is a prison movie, and look at how my films change in their life perspective. My debut film was dark and bleak and without hope. But Papillon is all about hope. And from where I was then to where I am now, and from the many movies I have been so lucky to have done, I just sense that there now is more hope in them.
And I think it’s because I am now the father of two kids. I don’t worry about my own life; I worry about their lives. I am not afraid of the moment where my life will fade away because I do feel that I am a part of something bigger. To me that is the magic of life, to have kids, and to be able to enjoy, and live off the work. I mean, I love movies, so to be able to make movies as well is a blessing. Maybe I am a little lighter at heart, but I do believe in love and hope, and I didn’t do that eight years ago. I didn’t feel then the way I do now.
Being a father has brought this to me. It was so funny to talk to Charlie and Rami about it. Because I do look at Papillon and Dega as two fatherless kids, and also as two men who don’t have kids. I think it’s very important in the portrayal of these two men that they don’t really connect to any family, no one before them, no one after them. They remind me so much of how I felt when I was in my 20s. And now in my late 30s, I am someone else. And there are so many fatherless kids in prison, as are Papillon and Dega as well, so they can’t live for what they have at home. They have to live for what they can create between each other. Of course, your life perspective changes as your life changes. So the way I talk about character and the way I direct movies changes according to how I look at life and what I’ve learned.
There were a lot of stunts, not so many special effects. I know that Steve McQueen in 1978 jumped off the cliff in the first film. Does Charlie Hunnam do that? I couldn’t quite tell if he was doing his own stunt or not, probably not.
Well, I think Charlie would have loved to have done it, but I don’t think anyone could have afforded the insurance. We would have had to do that as the very last shot, but I don’t think I would have had the nerve for it. But hats off to the guy who did do the jump because, as far as I know, it’s one of the biggest real jumps caught on film. You’re absolutely right, there are almost no computer effects or wires or anything like that. It is very much in-camera and I like that. To me it was a salute to an earlier director like David Lean, a salute to the movies that were made before New Hollywood in the ’70s. And I’m quite proud of that and like that a lot.
Did you watch other prison films about the brutality of institutional confinement to determine pitfalls you wanted to avoid, or insights you wanted to achieve? Films like I am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang (1932), Birdman of Alcatraz (1962), In the Name of the Father (1993), Shawshank Redemption (1994)?
Not really. I actually looked at something completely different. I looked at Pretty Woman. It is my mom’s favorite movie, and the reason it’s her favorite movie is because of the romance, the good music, and because the chemistry is so good, and the way the main characters develop and evolve and exchange roles. Over 90 minutes, Richard Gere totally shifts in his worldview, and so does Julia Roberts. Each becomes the other. I think that’s really what I felt was the potential for a movie like Papillon. Instead of being inspired by all kinds of other violent movies, it was much more interesting to do a violent-strong movie but to fill it up with as much melodramatic love story as possible. That really is the unique thing with Papillon, really the chemistry between those two characters and the way they evolve and exchange roles too.
At one point, you said that you’re “drawn to the masks that men are forced to wear in order to survive long-term incarceration. Behind those walls you have to play certain roles to not show your weakness. A prison is almost like a theater stage in that respect.” Tell me more about this.
You asked me if I had seen other prison movies. For me, going back into the prison environment was like standing on the shoulders of my own previous work because I did a lot of research when I did my initial prison film. Roland Miller is actually the one who inspired me. He was an ex-convict who played a particular character in my debut film. He had never acted before, had never been in front of camera, had never said one line, and he never, ever wanted to be an actor, ever. He had been incarcerated for several years. He knew the inside of a prison by heart. He’s the one who had said that it’s no problem to cast all inmates to be in a movie as they’re used to playing a role all the time. That’s how everybody tries to climb up the ladder of hierarchy because no one wants to show their vulnerability. That really was the essence of what I tried to convey in my debut film. And that’s also what I also took with me in making this new Papillon. Papillon and Dega have to remove the masks from each other so they’re bound within each other, and the moment the money runs out, all that they have left is each other. It’s something that’s a part of all my movies where I explore the theatrical roles we play for each other for all kinds of different reasons.

Read Ben Wiley’s review of Papillon here.
Ben Wiley taught literature and film at St. Petersburg College. At USF/Tampa, he was statewide Director of the Florida Consortium/University of Cambridge (UK) International Summer Schools. His interests are film, theater, books, and kayaking Florida rivers. He also writes the BookStories feature for Creative Loafing Tampa. Contact him here.
This article appears in Aug 16-23, 2018.


