Pickles and mustard on pizza may sound psychotic, but like with most pies, it all comes down to the crust. ABC Pizza has been perfecting its thick crust for nearly 60 years, which has a sweetness that can seemingly encase a Cuban sandwich’s core ingredients (ham, salami, pork, mayo, mustard, pickle, and cheese. And you call yourself a Tampeño) ideally. While you can order classics like a meat lovers or a veggie pizza, the Greek-run eatery—which has six locations in Florida—has also taken to putting cheesesteak and gyro toppings on its pies, while still being able to slap some lamb in between actual pita for the less bold ones in your life.
abcpizzahouse.com—Josh Bradley
This article appears in Best of The Bay 2024.
