The staff at downtown Tampa’s beloved slightly-larger-than-a-window shop can do a lot more than make the best breakfast sandwich Alton Brown has ever had. If you’re ever depressed about Supernatural’s weekly supply of donuts selling out in the blink of an eye, this sandwich, loaded with four meats, provolone cheese, LTO, and a rich, pepper-based mayo can put your sweet tooth to sleep for a few hours. Perhaps the most genius part is the fact that somebody thought to incorporate everything on ciabatta bread (which you can substitute for sourdough or Focaccia if you don’t want to overstretch your mouth). For an extra 50 cents, you can make the sammich spicy, and if you spend the extra $2 to add avocados? To hell with avocado toast, man. supernaturaltpa.com—Josh Bradley
This article appears in Best of The Bay 2024.

