3.5 out of 5 stars
1163 Dr. MLK Jr. N., St. Pete. Appetizers: $6-$12; entrees: $7-$23; dessert: $8; beer/wine/cocktails: $5-$10.
727-290-6166, nitallys.com.
For more than a decade now, fusion cuisine has been all the rage. But, I must say discovering Nitally’s ThaiMex’s new St. Pete location has me wondering about the origin story. Even though both cuisines embrace spice, I keep seeing visions of black sombrero-clad mariachi hitting on Tuptim and her Uncle Tom’s Cabin dancers from The King and I. But it seems I just got the costumes wrong.
What happens when a Mexican boy falls for the seductive twinkle in a Thai girl’s eye? They hook up and open a restaurant.
We sit at a high-top table with a shiny white lacquered milk can vase overflowing with brightly colored flowers. A vivid yellow container holds napkins, silver forks, spoons and chopsticks for sticklers to tradition. A single white pillar candle sits on a tall turned spindle—glossy with the loveliest shade of sea green. There’s also a diminutive A-frame with a chalkboard reminding guests of the “gift card available” with hearts dotting the “i”s. There’s neon spelling out BAR and a small torso of a sombrero-wearing skeleton proudly championing Day of the Dead “memento mori” imagery. It’s a lively room, both visually and aurally. There are counters with shiny corrugated aluminum on the walls flanked by brightly colored metal stools. Indigenous Mexican music adds to the pulse of energy; clearly the word is out. Diners have obviously made the migration from the South Pasadena location noted for the Buddha and sugar skull on the window.
The chalkboard drinks menu offers beer, wine, rum/tequila & Coke, or mason jars full of margaritas and sangria. The red wine version of the latter packs the jar with fruit, particularly thin wedges of apple that soak up the delightful concoction.
We start with chicharrones, those marvelous light, crunchy pork rinds here paired with red curry. An aluminum tray lined with brown paper sports a small plastic cup filled with the delicious sauce. It’s topped with a cilantro sprig and shredded red cabbage garnish, which is a nice visual. Even though Nitally’s is a casual joint, the attention to detail is a bonus for your senses.
A mason jar stuffed to the brim with shucked and lightly pan-roasted Mexican corn niblets is scrumptious. The corn is ever-so-lightly coated in a traditional lime marinade with mayonnaise, cojita cheese, and a blend of sugar, guajillo chili, and garlic. It’s hot, moist, and topped with cilantro plus a fresh lime wedge and totally winning.
One Asian influence on the menu is a super-fresh romaine lettuce wrap stuffed with savory sautéed chicken plus some crunchy, quickly cooked fresh veggies (sprouts, red cabbage, carrots, etc.). The large round tray has just enough room for some soy-based dipping sauce to round out the flavors.
Our entrées prove to be just as enticing. Pad Thai gives you protein options of beef, chicken, tofu or our choice of juicy shrimp. The tender rice noodles stir-fried with egg, onion, bean sprouts and red peppers are sprinkled with scallions, ground roasted peanuts and topped with a beautiful purple dendrobium orchid plus a cilantro sprig. A quick spritz of fresh lime adds just the right touch of brightness; it’s classic.
The chorizo fried rice, however, is a true cultural mashup. Traditional Thai style spicy fried rice is combined with seasonal veggies, carrots, Thai chili peppers, and a touch of garlic. When you add Mexican style chorizo made of minced pork, paprika, and Mexican spices, you get a love child with enough flavor to dance all night on your palate.
Pineapple red curry with chicken simmers the bird in coconut milk with tomatoes, carrots, and veggies. The addition of sweet basil and green peas makes both the flavor and color pop. Pineapple, of course, is the secret ingredient to add that unique flavor on the knife’s edge between sweet and tart. So you end up with a complex dish that hits all the notes on your tongue.
The desserts sound particularly intriguing. Thai-Ra-Misu is described as an “eye-perking” delicious coffee poundcake lathered in Thai espresso plus a house-made secret sauce and topped with whipped cream and maple cinnamon sprinkles. Or there’s the Tres-Leches Y Media, which is a “sinful“ poundcake creation lathered in a creamy concoction of homemade house sauce.
We’re ready to have one of each when our server announces that there’s no dessert available tonight. I secretly let out a primal scream and wonder what kind of bizarre religious holiday could produce such a tragedy. Alas, even though we’re deprived of sugar to help fuel our sojourn back up I-275, the ThaiMex experience confirms two oft-debated ideas. One, we’re better off by embracing other cultures — because diversity is a gift. And, finally, it’s best to charge forward in life without fearing the unknown. Who knows what objects of sweet desire may lurk right around the next corner?
CL Food Critic Jon Palmer Claridge dines anonymously when reviewing. Check out the explanation of his rating system, or email him at food@creativeloafing.com.
Want to know everything going on with Tampa Bay’s food and drink scene? Sign up for our Bites newsletter.
This article appears in Jul 18-25, 2019.



