As the galloping “Monarchy of Roses” opens Red Hot Chili Peppers’ 10th album and first new release in five years, I immediately notice Josh Klinghoffer’s back-up vocals. Fans of ex-RHCP guitarist John Frusciante’s solo material will recognize Klinghoffer’s unique, slightly effeminate voice throughout I’m With You. While Frusciante’s great riffs and solos will always be looked back upon fondly, Klinghoffer’s contributions sound more textural and rhythmic in this context. Despite the Chili’s collaborative approach – attributing songwriting credits to the whole band – Frusciante’s impact is oft-debated as the difference between One Hot Minute and Californication.
So my expectations for a new album by modern rock’s most ever-present band were impossibly low, a bar Red Hot Chili Peppers cleared all too easily.
I’m With You is somewhat of a departure from past material. The sound remains essentially that of the Red Hot Chili Peppers – Flea’s bass playing and Chad Smith’s drumming still fuel their funky engine. However, during the band’s hiatus, Flea studied music theory at USC and learned piano. (Isn’t it interesting that a professional musician with a very successful 30-year-career makes news when he goes to school to actually study music? But I digress.) New member Klinghoffer also tickles the ivories, and so we have a long-running rock group writing music on piano for the first time in their musical history. Between the band’s utilization of Klinghoffer’s bright but haunting backing vocals and their new-found emphasis on keys, RHCP seems to have traded the fun vibe for a somewhat off-kilter disjointedness with scattered emotion and poignancy.
“Brendan’s Death Song” is simultaneously mournful and celebratory of the friend whose death kick-started the songwriting on I’m With You, and epitomizes the life and death theme at the album’s core. Klinghoffer’s “oooh”-ing on “Annie Wants a Baby” scores the set’s emotionally unsettled nature. The simple piano melody and echoing guitars on “Police Station” evoke longing. Of the 14 tracks, “Ethopia” most resembles a prototypical RHCP radio tune from the past decade — but with some new quirks. By the time you near the album’s end, Klinghoffer’s beautiful verse in “Meet Me At The Corner” perhaps cements his role as Red Hot Chili Peppers’ new “X-Factor” going forward. (Out August 30 via Warner Bros.)
3 Stars
This article appears in Aug 18-24, 2011.

