There was a moment during the break on “TV” when Naked Giants drummer Henry LaVallee came off of his throne, sort of hunched over and just stared wide-eyed into the crowd as if he didn’t quite know what to do with all of energy his Seattle-based trio was emitting in front of a sold-out Orpheum in Ybor City.
LaVallee, who returned later in the night to play auxiliary percussion during Car Seat Headrest’s headlining set, didn’t have much time to think about it, however, because his bandmate Grant Mullen — who also returned on guitar for Car Seat Headrest’s set — launched into a searing guitar solo that was just one highlight of Naked Giants’ seven-song, 45-minute opening performance. The triumphant Tampa Bay debut of Car Seat Headrest — which put on a nearly 90-minute, 11-song show of its own — was even better.
Car Seat Headrest is the brainchild of Will Toledo, but on Saturday night the 26-year-old songwriter surrounded himself with a six-piece band that included LaVallee, Mullen and Naked Giants bassist Gianni Aiello on synth. Last week, Toledo told Creative Loafing Tampa that this would probably be the last time Car Seat Headrest’s core unit — guitarist Ethan Ives, bassist Seth Dalby and drummer Andrew Katz — and the Naked Giants crew would tour together.
“I think they wanna go and focus on their own stuff. When that happens we’re gonna reconfigure, basically, everything we’ve been doing live,” Toledo said, adding that Car Seat Headrest’s new album would reflect that reconfiguration. “ I think that we’re trying to build up a record that matches that.”
Toledo made the most of his company, however, and gave fans a taste of what that record may sound like by playing a new song, “Can’t Cool Me Down,” to open the set (another ‘80s-flavored new song, “Weightlifters,” was played, too). He then quickly launched into the big-bodied, synth and guitar-driven revelry of “Bodys” where he breached the fourth-wall by explaining what a pre-chorus is during the song’s, well, first pre-chorus. It was funny to find Toledo talking to his audience so literally on the cut because so much of Car Seat Headrest’s music speaks directly the woes and worries of a generation of nervous young people who can’t get out of own their angsty brains. That much was clear during a sing along of “Cute Thing,” a song about trust and love that also happens to be buoyed by a bridge that is also an interpolation of “Ana Ng” by They Might Be Giants.” Toledo is undoubtedly one indie-rock’s most clever songwriters, but he’s also getting out of his head and growing more and more comfortable as a frontman.
Not once did Toledo handle a guitar for an entire song. Yes, he played one during the bridge on “Maud Gone” (where Ives took lead vocal to open the tune), and Toledo did slip onto the synthesizer during “Can’t Cool Me Down,” but for the most part, the bespectacled wunderkind looked comfortable as a singer, pseudo body-rocking in half-time and occasionally brushing his mop top back confidently while the band unleashed waves of sound. He took command of a tambourine during a Crazy Horse cover (“Powderfinger”) which evolved out of a lilting and uplifting performance of “Sober To Death,” and if there was any doubt about whether or not Toledo wast having fun onstage, then all that needed to be seen was the moment on “America (Never Been)” when he and Mullen playfully exchanged hip thrusts during the song’s devastatingly beautiful and blown-out guitar freakout.
Right now, Toledo is a rock star not just in stride, but one evolving at a rapid pace (the guy was doing windmills with his arms during set-closer “Destroyed By Hippie Powers,” for chrissake). Saturday’s show’s was sold-out days before doors opened, and if the catharsis unleashed during “Drunk Drivers/Killer Whales” was any indication, then one more honest record peppered with at least one big chorus could find him headliner a much larger venue like Jannus Live on his next swing through town.
That appearance, however, could be a long way off since Toledo also told CL that there’s going to be a slightly longer gestation period before a new Car Seat Headrest album is released.
“I mean what we’re working on right now needs to come out. Then, usually, once one thing comes out, it’s easier to do the next thing,” Toledo said in our interview. “It’s kind of like changing phases.”
So, OK, there might be an extended break between Florida sets by Car Seat Headrest. But you’ve got to feel like fans are willing to wait and figure out what to do in the interim. At least their first date with Toledo left them definitely wanting more.
Listen to a playlist of songs from the show via Spotify.
Setlist
Naked Giants
Regular Guy
TV
Sluff
Curtains Blue
Twist
Green Fuzz
Ya Ya
Car Seat Headrest
Can’t Cool Me Down
Bodys
Cute Thing
Maud Gone
Weightlifters
Fill in the Blank
Sober To Death > Powderfinger (Neil Young & Crazy Horse)
America (Never Been)
Drunk Drivers/Killer Whales
Destroyed By Hippie Powers
—
Beach Life-In-Death
This article appears in Feb 21-28, 2019.


