
In movies, as in life, timing is everything. Actual substance counts a bit, of course, but when the two factors combine — as in Oliver Stone’s weak-sister World Trade Center being released on the heels of the similarly themed but far superior United 93 — it’s a no-brainer that the lesser film winds up relegated to the dustbin of history, forever filed away as “the other 9-11 movie” (or something equally dismissive).
A similar fate is almost certainly in store for Douglas McGrath’s Infamous, which has the misfortune of showing up in the wake of the significantly better Capote. Both films offer accounts of exactly the same period in the life of Truman Capote — when the writer was wrestling with his grand project, the researching and writing of In Cold Blood. But Infamous can’t begin to compete with the emotional and psychological richness of Capote, and (although its release was held up for a full year in order to put some distance between the two movies) McGrath’s film winds up almost completely swallowed by the shadow of its predecessor. For viewers familiar with both movies, Infamous may seem less an account of Capote’s life than simply a remake (and a so-so one, at that) of Capote.
That said, there are some curious, guilty pleasures to be had with Infamous, which despite (or maybe because of) its relative lack of depth, offers what some might consider a more, well, “fun” time at the movies than does Capote. Whereas Capote opened with the brutal murder that occasioned In Cold Blood and then unfolded like a tone poem charting its protagonist’s creative and moral turmoil, Infamous opens with zebra-skin banquettes and fashionable couples enjoying multi-colored cocktails in a chic Manhattan supper club. Think of Infamous as Capote-lite, a movie less about Truman the tortured artist and more about the other Capote, the weird little queen with the funny voice and the penchant for gossip and hanging out with celebrities.
Glitzy and occasionally overheated in ways that verge on camp, Infamous may strike some Truman-watchers as being more in keeping with the spirit of the “real” Capote, but it’s not particularly satisfying filmmaking. The movie is a bauble that desperately wants to be taken seriously, and (as Truman himself knew all too well) desperation is never very pretty to look at.
Director McGrath fills his film with famous people playing other famous people — Sigourney Weaver, Isabella Rossellini, Peter Bogdanovich and others portraying various celebrity and socialite friends of Truman’s — and then sets them up as a Greek chorus of talking heads who periodically address the camera in order to deliver pithy comments on what’s happening on screen.
Infamous gives us a very public Capote, played by British actor Toby Jones, who nails Truman’s distinctive mannerisms and whiny lisp in a performance that, while entertaining enough as impersonation, exists almost entirely on the surface. Not quite a caricature, but miles from the creature-of-substance definitively delivered by Philip Seymour Hoffman, Jones’ Capote spends much of his time rolling his eyes, dishing the dirt with famous friends or, in the sections of the film set in the wilds of Kansas, traipsing about in a flamboyant wardrobe hand-picked to get a rise out of the natives. There’s even a running joke made of Truman being constantly mistaken for a woman, and many of the other laughs generated from this material don’t take a much higher road.
The movie navigates pretty much the same bases as the ones covered in Capote — Truman travels to Kansas, where his interviews with a pair of killers ultimately put him way too close to his subject — but with a considerably broader, more theatrical style that doesn’t particularly suit the story being told. Capote masterfully explored the moral, aesthetic and psychological complications of a writer’s possible exploitation of his subject; Infamous seems more interested in the cute sparks resulting from the odd and quintessentially urbane Capote’s interaction with the local hicks.
The film spends so much time massaging something vaguely sitcom-like out of Capote’s relationship with the hoi polloi (Truman and local lawman Jeff Daniels even take to calling each other “Foxy” and “Partner”) that it’s hard to take Infamous all that seriously when some semblance of substance is eventually supplied. The first real whiff of gravity doesn’t occur until a full 30 minutes into the film, with a flashback to the Cold Blood killings (the same material Capote opened with), by which time it’s a classic case of too little, too late.
As if semi-conscious of its own failings, Infamous overcompensates during its second half with some bizarrely bombastic moves, beginning with a series of long, melodramatic monologues that seem to appear out of thin air, in which Truman and various other characters, lips atremble, agonize over issues with long-dead fathers and mothers. Somewhere, Tennessee Williams is turning over in his grave.
The film’s most audacious move, however, is to turn the homoerotic undercurrent commonly acknowledged in Capote’s relationship with killer Perry Smith into a bona fide love connection. It’s bad enough that Daniel Craig (yep, the new James Bond himself) is horribly miscast as the weasely little Smith, looking way too physically imposing and confident for the part (and yet faintly ludicrous in dyed black hair and eyebrows). But when you see 007 and Jones’ little elf lip-locked in a Brokeback Mountain moment, the scene doesn’t come off as particularly tender or romantic or even shocking. It’s just sort of silly and, well, desperate.
Although Infamous is arguably the gayest movie in town this week, the real action is over at the 17th annual Tampa International Gay and Lesbian Film Festival, which sprints into its final days this weekend.
There are still more movies to be seen than could possibly be covered in the space allotted here, so let’s just quickly mention some of the highest highlights. TIGLFF has screened several films on the Pinellas side of the Bay this year, and its final (and possibly biggest) Pinellas show will be In Dreams Awake (Oct. 11, 7 p.m., Muvico Baywalk), an upbeat but genuinely moving documentary about the late artist Bill Petrie. A reception and exhibition of Petrie’s paintings follows the screening at St. Pete’s Studio@620, 620 First Ave. S.
TIGLFF has some frighteningly good things in store for Friday the 13th, but the one film you really must check out is Shortbus (9:45 p.m., Channelside), the hugely controversial sex-travaganza from Hedwig and the Angry Inch director John Cameron Mitchell. (The film will probably show up eventually for a regular local run; then again, you never know.) A less racy but still recommended alternative to Shortbus is the French import Like a Brother (9:25 p.m., Tampa Theatre), a coming-of-age/coming-out piece with more than enough Euro flair and poetic sensibility to keep us engaged.
Saturday, Oct. 14 is another of the festival’s biggest days, and some of the best bets include the fascinating, funny and ultimately heartbreaking Go West (1 p.m., Tampa Theatre), a tale of star-crossed lovers, a gay Muslim and his Serb partner, in war-torn Bosnia.
Then we have two films at complete opposite ends of the aesthetic spectrum: Whispering Moon (3:30 p.m., Channelside), an artsy oddity about cute German boys and conspiracies involving poisonous frogs (or something like that); and the L.A.-set East Side Story (7:15 p.m., Tampa Theatre), a screwy but surprisingly soul-satisfying comedy that gently skewers tensions between the gay and the Latino communities. The evening concludes with the spectacularly ridiculous and gleefully offensive Another Gay Movie (9:10 p.m., Tampa Theatre), an American Pie for the queer crowd and anybody else with a sense of humor.
The festival winds down on Sunday, Oct. 15, with a pair of wonderfully witty comedies — Puccini for Beginners (5 p.m., Tampa Theatre) and Boy Culture (7:45 p.m., Tampa Theatre) — along with a massive street party beginning at 4 p.m. in honor of Tampa Theatre’s 80th birthday.
Enjoy the revelry while you can; the 18th annual Tampa International Gay and Lesbian Film Festival won’t be rolling into town until October of 2007. And with an event this good, a year between festivals can seem like a very long time.
The 17th annual Tampa International Gay and Lesbian Film Festival runs through Oct. 15, Tampa Theatre, 711 N. Franklin Street, Tampa; Channelside Cinemas, 611 Channelside Drive, Tampa; Muvico Baywalk 20, 151 Second Ave. N., St. Petersburg. For more information, go to www.tiglff.com or call 813-879-4220.
This article appears in Oct 11-17, 2006.

