On the surface, a proposal by the latest owners of Old Hyde Park Village to build more condos and rebuild restaurants and shops at the Tampa residential-retail center seems crazy, considering it’s in the middle of Tampa Bay’s most historic neighborhood. The surrounding controvery also seems like just another local civic association fight.

But the issue of urban redevelopment goes beyond just the well-bungalowed streets of Hyde Park. This is a lesson for every government and every neighborhood and every person in Tampa Bay.

Because Florida’s growth must be up, not out.

Here’s the deal: For almost three decades, Old Hyde Park Village has stood as an interesting urban oasis of shops, restaurants, movie theaters and low-rise condos amid expensive, restored turn-of-the-century bungalows and mansions. Nearly 30 years ago, it was hip and cool.

Or at least that’s the Old Hyde Park Village I knew when I first moved to Hyde Park in 1989. I lived there a year, and it was the first near-urban living experience I found in Florida. This was where some of the newspaper scribes indulged their alcoholism every night. The village was a great place to walk and window-shop at The Sharper Image.

Over the next two decades, though, the shopping district declined, its restaurants closing, its movie theater going dark. Larger entertainment complexes at Channelside and BayWalk took its place and its cachet.

Last year, a real estate fund bought Old Hyde Park Village. The buyers have come up with an ambitious $100 million plan that would add more housing than is currently on the site, another 200 units.

Unfortunately, some Tampa City Council members who understand the need for urban redevelopment are just too close (living in and representing South Tampa) to see their way past the disapproving neighbors who jammed last week’s City Council meeting.

In the end, council members voted 3-2 in favor of a rezoning. Joseph Caetano, Gwen Miller and Tom Scott were for it; Mary Mulhern and Linda Saul-Sena were against it; John Dingfelder recused himself because he has an office in Hyde Park; and Charlie Miranda was absent and now has the deciding vote at the Thurs., Dec. 20 council meeting.

I’m sure we could nitpick some parts of the proposal, but it is exactly the kind of urban development Tampa Bay needs. Residents could walk to shops and restaurants instead of choking the roads with cars. If they do need to drive, the new condo towers would be within spitting distance of the Selmon Crosstown Expressway.

Caetano put it this way during last week’s meeting: “”We’ll never be the next great city if we keep voting no to projects like this.”

If we hope for an urban landscape, we must endure the pain of building upward, not to ruin established neighborhoods but to strengthen them. West Tampa needs multi-story buildings lining Howard and Armenia; the Channel District needs more life and shops and restaurants; Westshore and Feather Sound need to develop better living communities as an option for the untold office workers who get on the highways to drive home to FishHawk Ranch or Pasco County.

I know the neighborhood leaders are going to hate to hear this, but our survival depends on change — urban change.