
The City of Clearwater holds its City Council elections next month with two of five seats up for election. The Seat 5 race in particular has had candidates debating one issue that has shaped Clearwater politics for decades: The growing influence of the Church of Scientology in the city’s downtown.
Candidates in Clearwater City Council Seat 5 race include:
- Former Councilmember and Mark Bunker, 70
- Former congressional staffer Sam Wilson, 26
- Businessman Kevin R.T. Laughlin, 67
Across downtown Clearwater, Scientology has purchased over 200 properties since 2017 leaving only seven commercial properties not affiliated with scientology or the government in 2024, according to the Tampa Bay Times.
The church’s influence in municipal matters was brought to the forefront starting in June when the City Council gave a 470-foot stretch of South Garden Avenue—a public road paid for by taxpayers—to the Church Of Scientology for no cost in a 3-2 vote reversing their original plan to sell the public land for $1.38 million.
The decision came following a highly unusual state-level intervention, triggered when Councilmember David Allbritton individually requested a non-binding opinion from Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier regarding the local street’s property boundaries.
In his letter, Uthmeier cited common law and said the church most likely owns that stretch of land under Garden Avenue. wrote, “In short, my answer to the first question is the Church most likely owns the land under the section of Garden Avenue at issue. “ …assuming the Church owns this section of Garden Avenue subject to the City’s easement, the Church can petition to vacate it without paying fair market value,” he added.
Former city attorney David Margolis argued the city still had the rights to the land since Clearwater had maintained it since the early 1920s.
This month, WUSF reported that, “Patricia Duggan, a Republican and Church of Scientology megadonor, gave $1 million to the Florida Freedom Fund, a PAC Uthmeier chairs.”
The church plans to permanently close the street and build a $250 million L. Ron Hubbard Hall auditorium with an adjacent memorial park and plaza open to the public. The church has asked for six years to complete construction.
In response, the grassroots coalition “Save the Garden” started a petition, looking to collect 7,000 signatures by mid-September in an attempt to force a voter referendum on the issue.
Scientology’s influence in downtown has become a dividing line in the Seat 5 City Council race. While all three candidates agree Clearwater needs a more active downtown, they disagree over how the city should deal with Scientology when trying to achieve that goal.
Wilson, a former staffer for U.S. Rep. Anna Paulina Luna, entered the race with support from many Republican officials and organizations. In addition, all three City Council members who voted in favor of the Garden Avenue transaction have endorsed Wilson including Allbritton who gave $100 to Wilson’s campaign.
Wilson has also received a public endorsement from Penny Jones, a self-proclaimed “Minister of the Church of Scientology.” In a now-deleted Facebook post supporting Wilson, Jones encouraged Clearwater residents to vote for him, describing him as someone who is “on our side.”
Wilson—who currently leads the race in fundraising, with over $20,000 raised between Q1-Q2—told Creative Loafing Tampa Bay that endorsements do not influence his decisions as a candidate.
“I can’t control who says what about my campaign,” he said. “No individual or group has a claim on my vote.”
Wilson has also faced questions about his connections to Clearwater’s business community, including Amplify Clearwater and its political action committee, clearPAC, which donated $500 to his campaign.
Public records show AMPLIFY Clearwater has had documented connections with Scientology affiliated organizations, including Flag Service Org. who has been an AMPLIFY member since 2025. Earlier records show Scientology hosted monthly networking events involving chamber members in 2015 and 2016.
Wilson argues the city shouldn’t ignore scientology but instead focus on if projects benefit residents. “If you’re going to do it, activate downtown,” he said.
When asked about how he would decide future land dispute votes he said, “The test is simple: does it help downtown and move the city forward?”
Bunker, who served on Clearwater City Council between 2020-2024, has been a vocal activist documenting and criticizing Scientology’s practices in Clearwater for more than two decades. The church’s influence over downtown is the central focus of his campaign. In a recent forum he said that a major reason he wanted to run was because he is concerned “the entire City Council may be controlled by Scientology.”
Bunker—who is rejecting any PAC donation—argues the city needs a more cautious approach when negotiating with the Scientology organization, saying “the city needs to monitor the process and ensure whatever businesses open are treated fairly.”
While Bunker told CL he would’ve voted no on the Garden Avenue land transaction he is not opposed to every project involving Scientology. When asked if he would support a Scientology-backed project that benefits Clearwater residents, Bunker—who founded XenuTV in the late-’90s—used the possible downtown theater as an example. “A theater downtown would be a tremendous draw and a good way to prove they are serious,” he said.
Wilson argues Scientology is a major property owner that Clearwater must work with. He was noncommittal in comments about the Garden Avenue vote, saying he hadn’t done the same amount of research as the current council members.
“[I] would only approve something if it activated downtown,” Wilson added.
The candidates have responded to each other’s positions, too.
Bunker argues the city must make sure pre existing commitments are fulfilled before giving the Church any more approvals. Wilson has criticized Bunker for focusing too much on Scientology without offering enough solutions for downtown, calling him a “single issue candidate.”
“If he wants to complain for the next couple years and achieve nothing, he can do that,” Wilson told CL. “But I’m focused on the future.”
Bunker said he is not opposing Scientology just for the sake of it, but he cares about making sure Clearwater keeps control over its decisions.
“My approach is based on decades of research to understand how Scientology works, resulting in a cautious approach where they have to produce what they promise before being rewarded,” Bunker said “Unlike Wilson, I wouldn’t foolishly blindly believe that Scientology has Clearwater’s best interest at heart.”
Laughlin, the third candidate in the race, said Clearwater’s downtown challenges go beyond just Scientology. He criticized the city’s handling of downtown property decisions and questioned whether enough has been done to protect public interests.
Laughlin opposed the Garden Avenue land transfer, saying, “Giving away a downtown street when expansion is what’s needed is a mistake.” He also pointed to the upcoming redevelopment of county owned properties as an opportunity for the city to prioritize projects that address Clearwater’s long-term needs, including transportation and parking.
The race comes as Clearwater faces many major decisions about downtown redevelopment and future property use.
Voting in the nonpartisan race for Clearwater City Council begins with early voting, which runs Aug. 8-16. Voting wraps on Election Day, Tuesday, Aug. 18. If no candidate gets more than 50%, a runoff will take place in the fall.
Seat 5 on Clearwater’s City Council is currently occupied by Lina Teixeira, who will not seek re-election.
Pitch in to help make the Tampa Bay Journalism Project a success.
Subscribe to Creative Loafing newsletters.
Follow us: Google News | NewsBreak | Reddit | Instagram | Facebook | BlueSky
This article appears in July 23 – 29, 2026.


