Situated on its own tiny island in the Pithlachascotee River, Tampa Bay’s famous “Moontide Isle” is no stranger to hurricanes. But after suffering significant damage from Hurricane Milton last month, the iconic island home is once again back on the market in New Port Richey.
Located at 5329 Richey Dr., “the island house,” as some locals call it, was built in 1946 and was given the name “Moontide Isle” by its original owner, a well-travelled cartographer who made it a point to incorporate artsy details into the home’s design, says the listing.
The main home comes with just two-bedrooms and two-bathrooms, as well as three fireplaces, built-in sculptures, its own moat traversed by a wooden foot bridge, and a full circle waterfront view. The estate is actually being sold as a three-parcel sale, which includes an adjacent two-bedroom, one-bathroom guest cottage with a pool and a covered boat lift, as well as another lot with a two-car garage. In a 2005 article from the St. Petersburg Times, Moontide was called “one of the most romantic houses ever built,” and the owners at the time, Jill and Rocky Marcus, told the publication that the house was in pretty bad shape when they bought it in 2002. “It’s the only house I’ve ever known of that came with its own sandbags,” said Jill to the publication.
Today, the home once again is in need of repair. As you can see in the photos, the home was pretty much gutted and is being sold “as a fixer-upper or a teardown after incurring flood water from Hurricane Milton,” says the listing.
According to property records, two parcels on the island last sold in 2021 for a combined $850,000. The asking price last December was $899,999, but the listing finally sold in March for $760,000 according to Zillow.
Every house has a story, and our mission is to tell Tampa Bay’s story through the lens of our community’s historic and colorful homes. Creative Loafing Tampa Bay’s real estate features are not ads, and are strictly operated through our editorial department. But we love public input. Do you know of a unique Florida home that we should highlight? Let us know, and email cwolf@cltampa.com.
Tampa Bay’s iconic private island home ‘Moontide Isle’
Situated on its own tiny island in the Pithlachascotee River, Tampa Bay’s famous “Moontide Isle” is no stranger to hurricanes. But after suffering significant damage from Hurricane Milton last month, the iconic island home is once again back on the market in New Port Richey.
Located at 5329 Richey Dr., “the island house,” as some locals call it, was built in 1946 and was given the name “Moontide Isle” by its original owner, a well-travelled cartographer who made it a point to incorporate artsy details into the home’s design, says the listing. The main home comes with just two-bedrooms and two-bathrooms, as well as three fireplaces, built-in sculptures, its own moat traversed by a wooden foot bridge, and a full circle waterfront view. The estate is actually being sold as a three-parcel sale, which includes an adjacent two-bedroom, one-bathroom guest cottage with a pool and a covered boat lift, as well as another lot with a two-car garage. In a 2005 article from the St. Petersburg Times, Moontide was called “one of the most romantic houses ever built,” and the owners at the time, Jill and Rocky Marcus, told the publication that the house was in pretty bad shape when they bought it in 2002. “It’s the only house I’ve ever known of that came with its own sandbags,” said Jill to the publication. Today, the home once again is in need of repair. As you can see in the photos, the home was pretty much gutted and is being sold “as a fixer-upper or a teardown after incurring flood water from Hurricane Milton,” says the listing.
See more photos here Credit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine KinnasCredit: Photo by Christine Kinnas
Colin Wolf has been working with weekly newspapers since 2007 and has been the Digital Editor for Creative Loafing Tampa since 2019. He is also the Director of Digital Content Strategy for CL's parent...
More by Colin Wolf
Eat your way through 10 days of Tampa Bay's best burger specials during Tampa Bay's Burger Week