A stock photograph by Prostock-studio/Shutterstock showing A stock image of two humans just working on their gains in the gym. Captured in a medium shot inside a modern fitness center, two athletic individuals pause to talk by a barbell bench press station. On the left, a blonde man wearing a black tank top and shorts sits on the workout bench holding a water bottle with a white towel draped around his neck; on the right, a man in a gray sleeveless hoodie and sweatpants leans against the loaded barbell while smiling, illuminated by warm overhead gym lights against a concrete pillar.
A stock image of two humans just working on their gains in the gym. Credit: Prostock-studio / Shutterstock

In recent Savage Love column, Gym Bod Gym Buds tells Dan Save about being outed four years ago in his hometown. He’s recently become interested in a new “fast friend” from a martial arts gym who’s become one of his closest friends. Gym bod wonders if he should come out to his bud. Here’s what Clair S. and Carly T.—Tampa Bay locals who’re developing a new advice column for Creative Loafing Tampa Bay—had to offer as an alternative response.—Ray Roa

First of all, it is very sad that you got outed. I’m sorry that happened. But whatever you do, don’t tell this guy you like him at the same time that you tell him you are bi.

We have all been in situations where we have been terrified to tell someone we like them and that is hard enough. We have not (us lady writers) had to come out to our friends because we are straight (even though we both drive Subarus) but we can imagine that that is even more difficult.

So let’s take this one step at a time.

If you feel like there is any chance that your buddy won’t want to be your friend if you come out to him, you should take things slowly. This would give you the space to gauge your friend’s reaction and, if it’s negative, you would be able to spare yourself a double rejection. Why force yourself to do both at once when you’ve had scary experiences of coming out/being outed in the past? 

But you should also ask yourself why you fear his rejection of your romantic feelings for him. Are there other things in your friendship that have happened that made you question whether he would be accepting of you regardless of your sexuality?

Because from what you mention, it seems like signs point to yes, he’s also gay or bi.  Or, is it your past experiences that give you pause about coming out to someone again? If you’re trying to keep a better control of the narrative than you had in the past, then the safe route would be to approach this in two simple and easy steps.

Step 1: tell friend you’re gay, read his feelings.

If they’re good feelings, then proceed to step 2: tell friend you’re gay FOR him and you’ve got two one-way tickets to Pound Town, USA.—Claire S. & Carly T.

“Tell Me About It” is a new, locally-produced column offering alternate responses to the ones Dan Savage presents in his long-running column, which appears in the back of Creative Loafing Tampa Bay’s print issue. Send your questions to rroa@cltampa.com and he’ll forward them over.

Read his 2016 intro letter and disclosures from 2022 and 2021. Ray Roa started freelancing for Creative Loafing Tampa in January 2011 and was hired as music editor in August 2016. He became Editor-In-Chief...