The Most Ironically Named Band in Tampa In a dank, poorly air-conditioned East Tampa storage unit absolutely jammed with musical equipment (and a sofa on which to recline providing you were wearing a Haz-Mat suit), the five members of Coma Girl spend the first 10 minutes of rehearsal making a cacophonous improvisational racket. The formless onslaught would be largely unlistenable at any volume; at full blast, it’s sanity-threatening. Four or five times, however, a memorable riff, standout melody or cohesive groove emerges briefly from the din. They’re fleeting, but it’s obvious that everyone in the room recognizes them for what they are, and chances are better than even that some of them will end up in the next batch of fully-realized Coma Girl songs. Said songs have generally been sprawling, jagged stop-and-go assaults able to leap tall rhythmic changes in a single bound, and they’re overlaid by Paul McDowell’s love-it-or-hate-it vocal exorcism. Coma Girl is known more for knocking the wind out of your mind than for embedding hummable tunes in it. But the first proper tune the quintet launches into tonight, a new one, is far more hook-savvy than earlier material — without sacrificing much, if any, of the band’s confrontational style.
“That’s been the way it’s been heading,” confirms drummer Adam Kayne. “The fat has been trimming itself.”
“I just don’t want the self-indulgent stuff anymore, you know what I’m saying? I’m bored with it,” says guitarist Marty Iglesias. “I want to move things along, get in, get out — fuck it. It’s not motivated by anything other than progression. I just like these tight little packages.”
Noisy-ass underground iconoclasts such as Drive Like Jehu, Big Black and The Jesus Lizard have obviously informed the nearly 2-year-old Coma Girl’s somewhat discordant sound. McDowell and Iglesias’ previous outfit, Solo Mayo, was a much more grating affair, and most of the other members are avowed indiephiles. As disturbing as their music can be, however, it’s always been slightly offset by a penchant for traditional melody and song structure. Now, those elements seem to be taking a more prominent position.
“I don’t feel like we’re abandoning anything,” Iglesias says.
“That stuff is still there, though, you know?” adds bassist Max Sysk.
Though Iglesias takes on the most responsibility when it comes to songwriting (“He’s the conductor,” McDowell states succinctly), everyone contributes. Guitarist Dave Kibby attributes Coma Girl’s evolution to an ever-increasing comfort factor.
“We’re starting to get used to the mix, to all of us (working together). Everyone’s got so much input,” he says. “We’re challenging ourselves to make something that someone would like to listen to, but that’s also challenging for us.”
“Material-wise, that’s the goal,” agrees Iglesias. “To make everyone like it, but still retain that off-center quality.”
The first batch of songs Coma Girl penned and recorded together remain unreleased, but are still making the rounds via handout CDRs. The disc sounds great and does a decent job of introducing a band with a singularly unique sound, but falls a bit short when compared to their intense live sets. A Coma Girl show is a volatile and contradictory thing, musically airtight and visually bewildering. The strange onstage chemistry between Iglesias and McDowell is palpable, the former an outgoing rock-god-in-waiting and the latter a disturbing eccentric, alternately introverted and beyond control. All of the members have, at one time or other, suffered various flailing-McDowell-induced injuries. His habit of playing brass instruments live has led to some mesmerizing moments of horn destruction.
“He was a trumpet smasher in sixth-grade band,” jokes Kayne. “We basically never know what Paul’s gonna do until it happens.”
That sense of uncertainty permeates everything Coma Girl does, from the shifting time signatures and continuing refinement of the music to the vibe of the live set. They’re big believers in going out, doing it and seeing what happens, which is quite a bit different from simply drifting with the tides. Iglesias and McDowell, who’ve played together for several years now, both revel in the notion that Coma Girl is so open-ended, such an eternal work in progress.
“That’s what I didn’t like about some of my past bands, that it felt like there was some kind of mission statement,” says Isglesias.
“This just seems like the freest thing,” McDowell agrees.
The quintet is headed into the studio this month to record eight new tracks; members say the resulting album will definitely be released. Hopefully, new product will inspire the band to more aggressive promotion because, for a group of their promise, their profile is disappointingly low. Most of Coma Girl’s many gigs come from admiring peers who call and book them — their fan base includes a buttload of fellow Bay area fringe acts. Kibby and Iglesias cite day jobs, relationships and assorted responsibilities as reasons for their rather slack promotional drive. Kayne, on the other hand, puts it more simply.
“We’re the laziest busy band in Tampa,” he says.
Music Critic Scott Harrell can be reached at 813-248-8888, ext. 109, or at scott.harrell@weeklyplanet.com.
This article appears in May 29 – Jun 4, 2002.

