12/17 Update: Check out "Honorable mentions: More best songs of 2008."
OK, here's my list. Look for the CL music team's Top 10 album lists to be posted Dec. 22-24, to coincide with our Top 10 issue that streets Christmas Eve.
Also, I've been seeing M.I.A.'s "Paper Planes" popping up on other best-of lists. The song topped my 2007 tally, so I decided to leave her off this year's – or else the Sri Lankan sensation would have definitely given Weezy a run for his cash money.
1. "Mr. Carter," Lil' Wayne (pictured) w/Jay-Z
Lil' Wayne, the self-proclaimed greatest rapper on earth, lives up to the claim on this amazing free-word association with a world-class hook. Weezy's distinctive Nawlins locution is wonderfully raspy as he bounces from brilliantly wacky pop-culture references ("Hector Camacho Man Randy Savage") to outstanding boasts like: "Two words you never hear, ‘Wayne Quit?'/ 'Cause Wayne win, and they lose/ I call them April babies, 'cause they fools." Jay-Z's guest verse is boss, but it's Weezy's dramatic delivery and mad genius lyrics that make this song my top pick for '08.
2. "Highly Suspicious," My Morning Jacket
Genre-hopping rockers My Morning Jacket's foray into funk is a stone-cold winner. Frontman Jim James pulls a Prince, singing falsetto about sexy mysteries like "peanut butter pudding surprise" – without a discernible hint of irony. Oh, yeah, and the thumping, make-you-wanna-hump backbeat is irrepressible.
3. "Slapped Actress," The Hold Steady
This isn't the first song in which the indie rank's fiercest bar band name-checks Ybor City, but it is The Hold Steady's finest. And that's saying something considering the gutter glory of "Killer Parties." On "Slapped Actress," the band has concocted a guitar-centric, articulate rush of adrenaline that rises and falls like a first-rate arena-rock offering – minus the gloss and lyrical goofiness.
This article appears in Dec 17-23, 2008.