How is it that a barely-funded series of web shorts produced during the writers' strike manages to be better than just about everything aired on TV?
Part of the reason is Joss Whedon, the man behind Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog. Whedon — of Buffy, Firefly and Serenity fame — is known for snappy dialogue, engaging stories and a keen talent for creating fan buzz. Last week he released Dr. Horrible with little fanfare, posting three fifteen-minute episodes throughout the week. You could view them for free on the Dr. Horrible site, but only through last Sunday.
Now they're $1.99 each on iTunes. And worth every penny.
There's nothing new to this comic tale of a nascent super-villain trying to make it into the big leagues, but when that story is told with Whedon's flair for dialogue, a half-dozen musical numbers and the comedy genius of Neil Patrick Harris in the starring role, it's gold. Whedon regular Nathan Filion plays Captain Hammer — the doctor's arch-nemesis — with oblivious, scene-eating verve and the entire production manages to be slick and humble at the same time.
That might be the ultimate appeal of Dr. Horrible. The countless home-made video blogs and shorts posted on Youtube and the like create an aura of low expectations for web films, making it easy for Whedon and crew to surpass the perceived potential at every step. The actors are better than the script, the script is better than the plot and the plot is good enough to generate some pathos and interest. Most of the laughs come from obvious slapstick or surprise — the head of the League of Evil is a villain called Bad Horse (the Thoroughbred of the Apocalypse), silently played by an actual horse in the show's final scene — but they work.
Experience has trained all of us to know in our bones that 99% of online entertainment is pure crap. Maybe the real lesson in Dr. Horrible is that a skilled storyteller and some out-of-work production pros can turn those lowered expectations into honest-to-goodness blockbuster fun.
This article appears in Jul 23-29, 2008.