The Glee Project Recap: "Generosity"

Alex performed the gospel hymn “His Eye is on the Sparrow,” a song that he associated with his father’s funeral. While Alex put all those bad memories and passion into an undoubtedly heartfelt performance, his vocals were more strained than they have ever been on the show. No matter: Both Ryan and Ian liked his performance. To my surprise Ryan mentioned writing a character that Mercedes and Kurt could take under their wing, since Alex is basically a love child of those two characters. So while I and other Glee fans thought Alex’s similarities to Kurt and Mercedes would be a bad thing, Ryan Murphy apparently sees it as an advantage.


Damien was next with “I’ve Gotta be Me” by Sammy Davis Jr. I don’t even know what to say. I’ve never liked Damien and I never will. He doesn’t have a great voice (which Ryan acknowledged after his performance) and although Ryan also called him “Mr. Personality,” that personality is about as delightful as stale bread.


I think Alex will take the prize. Who do you think will win?
  • I think Alex will take the prize. Who do you think will win?
Lindsay performed “Defying Gravity” from Wicked. As was the case with Alex, I didn’t find her vocals as strong as usual. Neither Ryan nor Ian had much to say, despite Lindsay saying that she was tired of playing Little Miss Perfect. After she left the stage, Ryan confided to Ian that he’s always leaned toward cutting Lindsay from the competition but has kept her around because the group (New Directions? The Glee Project contenders?) needs “a girl like her.” Well, with an attitude like that it seems like Lindsay really has no chance of winning and never has. So why drag it out?


Last up was Samuel with “My Funny Valentine.” His performance was too edgy and depressing for me, but Ryan and Ian seemed to like it. Ryan brought up that “different” kind of religious character again and blah blah blah — I really don’t care anymore.


In a twist ending, no one was eliminated this week. Instead of a final three performing in next week's finale, it will be a final four. Honestly, at this point I don’t think the performances count for much. With the exception of Damien, all of the finalists are great singers, but the fact is you don’t have to be a great singer to be a star on Glee (*cough* Cory Montieth *cough*). I think it will come down to who Ryan and the mentors like the most, which I think makes it a competition primarily between Alex and Samuel. If I have to guess, I think Alex will take the prize, although Ryan really seems intent on this whole alternative religious character, so it could go either way.

  • Kevin McHale (left) judging this week's HW Challenge

"Generosity" was the theme this week on The Glee Project. If you’re confused as to how one can test generosity in a singing competition, you’re not alone. Yeah, the Glee cast is like a big family, but how does one convey generosity by singing a song? The four remaining contenders tried to reveal their charitable sides with a performance of Bill Withers' “Lean on Me,” and even though guest judge Kevin McHale (Artie on Glee) didn’t seem to have any specific criteria with which to judge, he ultimately anointed Lindsay the winner. So Little Miss Perfect finally wins a Homework Challenge; too bad the competition is practically over.

For the group number, the contenders performed “Sing” by My Chemical Romance. Not only did they have to pretend to play instruments during the video shoot, they also had to perform with children. Each contender was paired with and told to mentor a kid from a school whose music program was lost to budget cuts. Here the contenders could really show off how generous and helpful they could be, and while Lindsay and Samuel hit it off with their mentees, Alex had trouble connecting and Damien seemed to learn more from his kid than vice versa.

When it was time to reveal the bottom three, the contenders were instead greeted with a little twist. Rather of singing for the mentors and Ryan Murphy, those remaining would be performing for Ryan and Glee co-creator/writer Ian Brannan. And since Ian had never seen any of them perform, all of the remaining contenders would have to take the stage.

WE LOVE OUR READERS!

Since 1988, CL Tampa Bay has served as the free, independent voice of Tampa Bay, and we want to keep it that way.

Becoming a CL Tampa Bay Supporter for as little as $5 a month allows us to continue offering readers access to our coverage of local news, food, nightlife, events, and culture with no paywalls.

Join today because you love us, too.

Scroll to read more Events & Film articles

Join Creative Loafing Tampa Bay Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.