Theater Review: Sex, violence and beautiful music in the gripping Opus at American Stage

Opus starts as the tale of Grace, the violist, who is auditioning for a space with the celebrated Lazara String Quartet. The group’s usual violist Dorian has disappeared, and since he was manic-depressive and well-known for erratic behavior, there’s no telling what may have happened to him. Along with Grace, we meet the remaining members of the quartet: Elliot, first violin, Alan, second violin, and Carl, cello. They’re in a hurry to find a replacement for Dorian because they’re scheduled to play a nationally televised concert at the White House, and they’ve chosen a piece — Beethoven’s Opus 131 — that’s notoriously difficult.


[dataBox]


As Grace’s relationship with the group evolves, we learn more about the musician who preceded her and the three men she wants to work with. Dorian, we’re shown in flashbacks, was the acknowledged genius of the group, the one who made the most extreme demands on the others, and who was most often right. He was also, for a while anyway, Elliot’s lover — they lived together until Elliot grew tired of the relationship. Alan is a womanizer who looks for hookups on every tour, and who seems to have pegged anxious Grace as his latest conquest. Carl is a cancer patient who’s about to find out whether the disease is in remission or has spread to other parts of his body. As for Grace, she’s a wonderful musician but a nervous and not quite honest individual: she’s still secretly tempted by news of an opening at the Pittsburgh Symphony.


On Michael Newton Brown’s elegant set — a raised mahogany platform shaped to remind us of a violin — these five characters try to create music in the midst of willfulness, petulance, sexual feelings, personal ordeals, perfectionism and mental debility. Fortunately, the music they make isn’t just an offstage rumor: repeatedly, the four main characters mime playing while gorgeous melodies come over the loudspeakers. It’s enough to make you download six string quartets to your ITunes account.


All five actors in the show turn in fine performances, but the real standout is Steve Garland, whose Dorian is an imposing figure, self-confident to the point of arrogance, desperately in love with classical music, painstaking and pained and not entirely sane. When he’s handed a priceless viola in one late scene, the devotion he shows it is almost religious in its intensity, and we can’t help but feel with him his limitless reverence.


As his sometime lover Elliot, Steven Flaa is the quartet’s Supernerd: pedantic, professorial, no-nonsense and no humor. Dan Matisa as Alan is the hardest to place of the musicians: he’s likable enough, but he never really comes across as a Don Juan, and his intentions toward Grace just aren’t evident in his actions. But Ricky Wayne is superb as emotional cellist Carl. Wayne’s Carl is capable of the most benign camaraderie and the most intimidating severity: with his wiry frame and black beard he’s the very image of the artist as temperamental visionary.


And finally, there’s the gifted Tracie Thomason as Grace, a woman who’s never entirely comfortable with others — or with herself. Thomason’s Grace is pretty much an oddball — you can easily imagine her choosing to study her music while all the other kids were out on the playing field, or necking in the woods.


Dan Lombardo’s direction is impeccable, as are Mike and Kathy Buck’s costumes — extra-casual for practices, utterly formal for performance. T. Scott Wooten’s sound design would please an exacting Brahms.


And Opus pleases consistently. At the least it’ll enlarge your respect for classical musicians. At the best it’ll win your eyes — and your ears.

You’ve got to hand it to playwright Michael Hollinger. At a time when classical CD sales are minuscule and shrinking, when most Americans couldn’t tell you the difference between a violin and a viola, when once-famous names like Heifetz, Menuhin and Stern are virtually unknown except to music students, he writes a play about a string quartet that’s not only entertaining but, at times, gripping.

Who would have guessed that a drama about four string players could feature rivalry, violence, mental illness and romance? Who would expect that one of the characters in the play would assert that two others will never have a sexual relationship because “if you do I’ll cut your dick off”? Opus may not have any grand vision about the musician’s art, but it’s intelligent, suspenseful, funny and, most of all, convincing. Its real subject is politics — the politics of chamber music. The wonder, it turns out, is that the music happens at all.

WE LOVE OUR READERS!

Since 1988, CL Tampa Bay has served as the free, independent voice of Tampa Bay, and we want to keep it that way.

Becoming a CL Tampa Bay Supporter for as little as $5 a month allows us to continue offering readers access to our coverage of local news, food, nightlife, events, and culture with no paywalls.

Join today because you love us, too.

Scroll to read more Local Arts articles

Join Creative Loafing Tampa Bay Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.