Concert review: Surfer Blood and The Drums at State Theatre, St. Petersburg (with photos)

They briskly burst into their 10-track repertoire from their much-loved 2010 debut, Astro Coast. Their energy was a little subdued, but genuine. A bunch of college-age kids fresh off the heels of an apartment-recorded CD that’s pushed them into veritable indie superstardom, Surfer Blood served up a set that really felt more just-going-through-the-motions than anything.


The modest swell of arms peaking and bouncing front and center showed there were a few people feeling it, but not as many as I’d initially anticipated.


[image-1]“First and foremost it's a great guitar album,” Pitchfork.com wrote in their review of Astro Coast. For the most part, this statement rings true. The album's guitars are crunched and beefy, pillars the rest of the music almost latches onto. Live, I expected sheer guitar volume broaching quad-amped, Dinosaur Jr. levels.  This was, apparently, not so.


Subjected to a heavily-lopsided mix, Surfer Blood’s guitars were insipid, modest, and generally drowned-out in a vigorously loud sea of drums and vocals. It was so apparent, too. Trying to hear that one riff you like in that one song was pretty much a mandatory effort at every juncture.


A bad mix is one of those problems that you can't always blame on the band. Bad sound guy, overcontrolling tour manager, evil knob-turning henchman? It’s not worth postulating here, but the point is, while some criticisms are born out of a band's direct action (dead-eyed gyrations, for instance), other factors leave the person who's really responsible a mystery.


For such a setback, they did all right. The two new numbers they introduced into the set sounded quite promising, more confident, and, overall, a fitting jump from Astro Coast to lesser-explored territories. Clocking in just around an hour, Surfer Blood’s set proved their competence as musicians, even if their skills were muddled in the swath of an unfavorable mix. Here’s to next time.

Chalk it up to a bad mix or some mid-tour malaise, but something was off at Sunday night’s Surfer Blood / Drums show. [All photos by Mike Wilson.]

Openers The Drums (full disclosure: previously unheard) played a brand of New Wave-derivative tunes mottled in tired phrases of beach-dom and surfing of the sort that's so vigorously infiltrated the music scene this summer, but that — let’s be honest here — lost its luster, like, two weeks ago.

Sound wise, they came off as rich and lively but grew more and more calculated and predictable as their set progressed. They were skilled, no doubt about it; the mix was pleasingly balanced and they sounded, what I’d guess to be, pretty true-to-album.

The issue, though, is the Drums sound more like an amalgamation of influences than a full-blown creation. A mixed breed of recognizable indie chart-flirters from the past 10 years, with a little bit of Julian Casablanca’s sleepy croon here, a splash of high-note, arena-filling Killers chorus there, and a little Franz Ferdinand pomp sprinkled generously throughout. Immediately lively, but  contextually tired.

The lead singer's palsied gyrations didn’t help much, either. Dead-eyed and lanky, his moves harkened images of the late Ian Curtis almost too well except, you know, sans the legendary music behind him. The Drums repertoire seems too cheery for his whole weird, possessed schtick, and just ended up making the whole ordeal kind of off-putting after a few songs.

After a quick takedown and subsequent set-up, the kids of Surfer Blood [pictured above] took the stage to the sounds of the Jurassic Park theme. “It’s good to be back in Florida,” leadman J.P Pitts remarked in his longest non-singing sentence of the night.

WE LOVE OUR READERS!

Since 1988, CL Tampa Bay has served as the free, independent voice of Tampa Bay, and we want to keep it that way.

Becoming a CL Tampa Bay Supporter for as little as $5 a month allows us to continue offering readers access to our coverage of local news, food, nightlife, events, and culture with no paywalls.

Join today because you love us, too.

Scroll to read more Music News articles

Join Creative Loafing Tampa Bay Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.