While feds urge cell phone ban in cars, Florida legislators are proud there's no such law here

The National Safety Council reported earlier this year that at least 23 percent of all traffic crashes — or at least 1.3 million crashes — involve cell phone use per year. An estimated 1.2 million crashes each year involve drivers using cell phones for conversations and at least 100,000 additional crashes can be related to drivers who are texting. Cell phone conversations are involved in 12 times as many crashes as texting.


Recent studies show overwhelmingly that people realize that using a cell phone in their car, especially for texting, is dangerous. Yet they invariably say they're responsible drivers, and that it's the other guy or gal who needs to be scrutinized more closely.


Currently 35 states and Washington D.C. ban texting while driving, while 10 states (including California) ban hand-held cell phone use. Thirty states ban all cell phone use for beginning drivers.


And Florida? Again, nada.


Once again Sarasota-based Republican Nancy Detert is proposing a modest bill, SB 416 (over a dozen were filed in the legislature last year), that may be hard-pressed to get an up or down vote in next year's session. Detert told Kennedy with the Post:


"I have made the bill as small as I can make it and still have it worthwhile," Detert said, acknowledging the opposition. "In Florida, we're not exactly a leader on these kind of things."


That would be an understatement. Also in Kennedy's piece is this quote from Speaker Cannon:
"We have to be careful. In the good intention name of trying to keep people from getting hurt, it is easy to overly constrain individual freedoms that have differentiated our country."


Some comments need no editorial flourish. Let's just say that nobody should be banking on hard data or common sense to change these lawmakers' minds when it comes to this issue.


One other thing — you'll often hear lawmakers complain that this is a difficult issue for law enforcement, and do we want them checking and inspecting motorists if they're using a cell phone?


The fact is such laws are deterrents. The fact that texting while driving would be against the law would not stop everybody from doing it, but would significantly reduce such use. And that would make our roads safer.

Exactly 11 months ago, CL wrote a story about the fact that Florida was among the few remaining states that place no restrictions on cell phone use in an automobile. A number of bills were filed by the legislative session in 2011 to address texting while driving, but they went nowhere.

How sad is it, then, that on the same day that the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) urges all states to impose total bans on cell phone use in cars except for emergencies, Florida legislators boast that there's no such law in the Sunshine State, and if they have their way, there will never be one?

Take House Speaker Dean Cannon, who makes it an issue of personal freedom. He forgets the fact that everybody who turns on the ignition and drives on a public road is involved in a social compact of sort with other motorists — an agreement that we'll all obey the rules and drive as safely as possible.

Unfortunately, accidents happen, sometimes fatal ones. The fact is that using a cell phone, and especially texting while driving, has led to even more accidents. But what say Cannon about any such law? Well, he says he's uneasy about adding ""one more layer of prohibitive behavior," and went on to tell John Kennedy with the Palm Beach Post:

"I've heard evidence that eating fast food, or men fixing their ties, or women fixing their makeup, or talking to screaming kids in the back of the van — as I've done from time to time — is just as distracting, perhaps more so, than sending someone a text message," Cannon said.

WE LOVE OUR READERS!

Since 1988, CL Tampa Bay has served as the free, independent voice of Tampa Bay, and we want to keep it that way.

Becoming a CL Tampa Bay Supporter for as little as $5 a month allows us to continue offering readers access to our coverage of local news, food, nightlife, events, and culture with no paywalls.

Join today because you love us, too.

Scroll to read more News Feature articles

Join Creative Loafing Tampa Bay Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.