Surprisingly, no local restaurants cracked the top 10. But Tampa Bay restos are still all over this list, with about 20% of Yelp’s highest ranked restaurants calling the Tampa Bay area home.
Yelp says it landed on its final list using “a number of factors,” including “the total volume and ratings of reviews between January 1, 2022 and January 1, 2023. When available, all businesses on this list have a passing health score as of January 9, 2023.”
So with that said, here are all the local restaurants that made the cut (along with their rankings):
20. Rice & Spice
11625 Sheldon Rd, Tampa, (813) 475-6955
“The food at Rice and Spice is truly outstanding. I had the pleasure of trying the off-menu Tokio Showdown roll, which was absolutely delicious. The roll was bursting with flavor and had the perfect balance of textures. But what really made the roll stand out was the paired sauce, which was simply divine.” – Jerimy B. Credit: Photo via Yelp22. Fork & Hen
2801 N Tamiami Trl, Sarasota, (941) 960-1212
“A 5 Star experience. The Spicy Parmesan wings, were the Best wings I have ever had. Love the chicken & waffles. We want to walk thru the menu & try it all. This is the kind of place, which everything is fantastic. We will return soon.” – Steve L. Credit: Photo via Yelp
Best Bakery (Bread)
Mazzaro’s Italian Market
Finalists:La Segunda Bakery, The Sourdough Co.Credit: Photo via Mazzaro's Italian Market/YelpCredit: Photo via Yelp35. Uptown Eats
689 Dr Mlk Jr St N, Ste D, St. Petersburg, (727) 810-3287
“I can see why people rate this restaurant 5 stars. It’s just that good. The most delicious eggs I’ve ever eaten. Not sure why. Cooked to perfection. Seasoned with a very different seasoning that was outstanding. Fresh made country sausage. I must admit I’m not a biscuit lover, but wtf. Can’t wait to go again.” – Mark K. Credit: Photo via Yelp36. Box Of Cubans
10451 Gibsonton Dr, Riverview, (813) 677-1123
“Favorite Cuban sandwich! Set the bar so high that there is no sense in attempting anything else!” – Geovanie M. Credit: Photo via Yelp40. Château 13 Restaurant & Wine Bar
535 13th St W, Bradenton, (941) 226-0110
“If I could give six stars I would. First off, the owner Jen is absolutely wonderful. She is very hospitable and knows her stuff. She got it right from the food to the Ambiance. Chris was a fantastic server. The food is so delicious and fresh. A must try is the sweet potato soup. Also they offer the Caesar Salad with Anchovies which never happens. The wine list is extensive. Overall an awesome place. My advice. Make a reservation first. Enjoy!” – Derinda C. Credit: Photo via Yelp45. Izakaya Tori
310 S Dale Mabry Hwy, Ste 160, Tampa, (813) 875-4842
“I’m gonna say it… I think this is the best sushi in Tampa. My go-to used to be Soho Sushi, but Izakaya Tori beats them in taste and price. They also offer a wide variety of other Japanese dishes and ramen.” – Annah P. Credit: Photo via Yelp
Best Diner
Lenny’s Restaurant
Finalists: Trip’s Diner, Bacon Street Diner
Credit: Photo via Lenny’s Restaurant/Yelp54. Dry Dock Waterfront Grill
412 Gulf Of Mexico Dr, Longboat Key, (941) 383-0102
“Our favorite place on Longboat Key! Great good and friendly service. Great view of Sarasota Bay. Seafood linguini with grouper is a favorite.” Kevin M. Credit: Photo via Yelp60. Oxford Exchange
420 W Kennedy Blvd, Tampa, (813) 253-0222
“Great food, beautiful esthetic, amazing champagne Overall a great place to have brunch. Loved it!” – Mayra P. Credit: Photo via Yelp61. Cafe Soleil
4695 Gulf Blvd, Dolphin Village, St. Pete Beach, (727) 800-2970
“Great option for a quick coffee and pastry break. Great croissants that taste as if from a real French bakery. Staff is very friendly and welcoming.” – Kamryn P. Credit: Photo via Yelp63. KOJO
1289 North Palm Ave, Sarasota, (941) 536-9717
“AMAZING dinner in Sarasota. We absolutely loved the tuna pizza.. this place is great! Service, ambiance and food was fantastic. We cannot wait to get back” – Victoria M. Credit: Photo via Yelp66. Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza
1101 S Fort Harrison Ave, Clearwater, (727) 443-4900
“Great food. Great service. Quaint Old Coal Oven Pizza. It’s simply the best. Margherita Pizza is my favorite.” – Eric G. Credit: Photo via Yelp67. Willow’s Cafe
436 Central Ave, Sarasota, (941) 217-5856
“Great little find! My daughter said best lemonade ever. The whipped caramel coffee was divine. We ate street side and still got impeccable service while she was the only one waiting tables. Food was quick and very good. Had the shrimp & avocado Benedict & she had the vanilla cinnamon pancakes. Would for sure recommend.” – Sharon G. Credit: Photo via Yelp72. Pia’s Trattoria
3054 Beach Blvd, Gulfport, (727) 327-2190
“I had it on good word that Pia’s was a special place, and indeed it is. It was perfect for a night on the patio. The patio on the other side is pretty big, yet feels quaint and intimate. We started with martinis, what else?” – Mayra F. Credit: Photo via YelpCredit: Photo via Wright's Gourmet House75. Mangos & Marley A Coastal Cafe
506 Main St, Dunedin, (727) 253-4414
“Best little spot in town for good vibes, good food and good company.
My favorite is the Cuban bowl, it’s delicious and well balanced. But everything I’ve had I’ve liked so far so I don’t really think you can go wrong.” – Katrina L. Credit: Photo via Yelp80. Clear Sky Cafe
490 Mandalay Ave Ste 1, Clearwater, (727) 442-3684
“The have a great variety of options breakfast food from burritos, pancakes, eggs Benedict and more. They even had a Bloody Mary station that had a variety of rims and toppings!” – Michelle H. Credit: Photo via Yelp85. Meliora
1920 Hillview St, Sarasota, (941) 444-7692
“This is one of those gems that won’t need reviews to drive attendance, as word of mouth already seems sufficient, and will surely carry through to create a hard-to-get by high season.” – Robert C. Credit: Photo via Yelp88. Daily Eats
901 S Howard Ave, Tampa, (813) 868-3335
“Great place for breakfast. I had an amazing breakfast sandwich with corn beef hash. The home fries are some of the best I have ever had, order them extra crispy!” – James C. Credit: Photo via Yelp